Paperonium

Pancreatic cancer · Sci Adv · 2023

The paper’s summary: removing nerve-support cells “promoted” pancreatic cancer. In its own mice, removal slowed it.

Summary and opening sectioncells removed: more cancersame as the blank treatmentIts own mouse experimentcells removed: less cancer
Summary and opening sectioncells removed: more cancersame as the blank treatmentIts own mouse experimentcells removed: less cancer

Which way the cancer went after the nerve-support cells were removed

The paper says

Pancreatic tumors contain nerve-support cells (Schwann cells). One sentence in the paper’s short summary at the top, and one in its opening section, say that removing these cells from the pancreas “promoted” tumor formation. Read literally, that means the cells hold the cancer back.

Its own data show

In its own mouse experiment, removing the cells meant longer survival and less tumor growth (13 mice) than a blank treatment (12). Of 17 main-text statements that say which way removing or blocking the cells (or a gene active in them) moves the cancer, 15 agree with the mice. The 2 above do not.

If removing something holds a cancer back, that something was helping it. The rest of the paper says so, and builds a proposed treatment on it. A reader of the summary alone could think the cells hold cancer back, though two other sentences there say otherwise. The fix: “attenuated” (weakened) for “promoted”. No correction has been issued.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Tumor-associated nonmyelinating Schwann cell–expressed PVT1 promotes pancreatic cancer kynurenine pathway and tumor immune exclusion · Sci Adv (2023) · doi:10.1126/sciadv.add6995