Paperonium

Child nutrition · JAMA Netw Open · 2023

Paper says garden-and-cooking lessons cut blood sugar 0.02 points; its own range, 0.03–0.14, centres on 0.085

The paperoutside its own range, 0.03–0.14Middle of that rangewhere the figure must sitIts table: fell 0.03 vsrose 0.06a gap of 0.090.02should be inside0.0850.030.140%-points0.050.10.15no difference
The paperoutside its ownrange, 0.03–0.14Middle ofthat rangewhere the figuremust sitIts table: fell 0.03vs rose 0.06a gap of 0.090.02should be inside0.0850.030.1400.050.10.15no difference%-points

Drop in HbA1c, schools with lessons versus without, in percentage points

The paper says

The paper says gardening, nutrition and cooking lessons cut children’s HbA1c (a blood test of average blood sugar, in %) by 0.02 percentage points versus schools without lessons. In its summary, results and table it gives that drop a range of 0.03 to 0.14.

Its own data show

But 0.02 lies below that whole range, whose middle is 0.085. The table’s own before-and-after numbers agree with the range, not with 0.02: HbA1c fell 0.03 at the 5 schools with lessons and rose 0.06 at the 5 without, a gap of 0.09.

A range is the spread of sizes the data fit, and it must contain the paper’s own figure; in this kind of analysis the figure sits at its exact middle. So 0.02 is the odd one out. The data still show a drop, but about 4 times the 0.02 the paper calls small and possibly unimportant for health.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Effects of a School-Based Nutrition, Gardening, and Cooking Intervention on Metabolic Parameters in High-risk Youth · JAMA Netw Open (2023) · doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.50375