Paperonium

Psychiatry · Hum Brain Mapp · 2022

The paper’s best brain measure for spotting schizophrenia: 84.09% accurate. Its table: 80.68%; another beats it.

Range entropy is best80.68%Its table84.09%The paperRange entropy, healthy people onlythe paper used this rowSample entropy’s best82.95%Its table75%808590
Range entropy is best80.68%Its table84.09%The paperRange entropy, healthypeople onlythe paper used this rowSample entropy’s best82.95%Its table75%808590

Spotting schizophrenia: share of people labelled correctly (coin-flip guessing gets 50%)

The paper says

The paper rates how irregular brain activity is in scans with seven measures, and has a computer use each to tell healthy people from people with schizophrenia, bipolar disorder or ADHD. For schizophrenia it names one measure, “range entropy”, best, labelling 84.09% of people correctly.

Its own data show

Its own results table gives 21 schizophrenia results: each measure on three ways of dividing the brain into regions. The top is “sample entropy”, 82.95%; range entropy’s best is 80.68%, second. None reaches 84.09%. That number is in the table, but as a different score: range entropy called 84.09% of the healthy people healthy.

Accuracy counts everyone: patients labelled ill plus healthy people labelled healthy; coin-flip guessing gets 50%. A score on healthy people alone ignores the patients, so it is not accuracy. The summary’s main message is which measure suits each illness. For schizophrenia, its own table points to sample entropy, not range entropy. Its ADHD and bipolar picks match the table.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

The complexity of spontaneous brain activity changes in schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and ADHD was examined using different variations of entropy · Hum Brain Mapp (2022) · doi:10.1002/hbm.26129