Paperonium

Psychiatry · Psychol Med · 2021

Summary: depressed, overweight people have 2.44 times the odds of high inflammation. Its counts: about 11.

The summary, as printedIts own table’s countsThe same 2.44, read as apower of 2.71811.5 times2.44×1.283.9410.9×3.547.93.651.41×2×5×10×20×50×same odds
The summary,as printedIts own table’scountsThe same 2.44,read as a powerof 2.71811.5 times2.44×1.283.9410.9×3.547.93.651.41×5×20×100×same odds

Times the odds of high inflammation for depressed, overweight people, with likely ranges

The paper says

The summary says people both depressed and overweight have 2.44 times the odds of a high reading (3 mg/L or more) on a blood test for inflammation (range 1.28 to 3.94). Odds: how many have a high reading for each one who doesn’t.

Its own data show

Its table: 26 of 69 depressed, overweight people had a high reading (43 didn’t); 3 of 57 normal-weight, non-depressed people (apparently the comparison group) did (54 didn’t). (26÷43)÷(3÷54) = 10.9 times the odds, before adjusting for age and gender. Its results even print a times-the-odds figure of −4.39 for that group; none can be negative.

The paper’s method gives raw results as powers: odds multiply by 2.718 (a fixed number) raised to that power, so a negative power means lower odds. Its figures look like powers: 2.718 to the power 2.44 is 11.5 times (range 3.6 to 51.4). If so, the summary’s three odds figures (2.44, 1.52, 1.09) are 2.7 to 4.7 times too small.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

The influence of comorbid depression and overweight status on peripheral inflammation and cortisol levels · Psychol Med (2021) · doi:10.1017/S0033291721000088