Paperonium

HIV care · Lancet Reg Health Am · 2022

HIV trial promised hair tests and missed-appointment counts. Its paper reports neither and never says so.

The public planJuly 2016, never editedThe paperJune 2022Main measuresMissingHair testsStudy check-ups attendedMissed clinic appointmentsHair testsnever reportedStudy check-ups attendednot listedMissed clinic appointmentsnever reported
The public planJuly 2016,never editedThe paperJune 2022MainmeasuresMissingHair testsStudy check-upsattendedMissed clinicappointmentsHair testsnever reportedStudy check-ups attendednot listedMissedclinic appointmentsnever reported

Each measure’s place in the trial’s public plan and in the paper

The paper says

A trial of 360 people with HIV who had dropped out of care tested whether a doctor-led programme helps them take their drugs and stay in care. The paper cites its public plan, explains two departures from it, and concludes the programme may improve pill-taking.

Its own data show

The trial’s plan, posted on ClinicalTrials.gov (a public website for trial plans) before anyone joined, promised hair tests, which measure the HIV drug’s level, and a count of missed clinic appointments. Those promises were never edited. The paper reports no hair-test results, counts attendance at the study’s own check-ups instead, and mentions neither change.

Trials post their plan in advance so readers can check that the promised measures get reported. Attending the study’s check-ups, with $10 paid for travel, mostly shows who stayed in the study, not whether they kept clinic appointments in between. Without hair tests, the pill-taking conclusion rests only on patients’ own answers, with no drug-level measure to check them.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

A small cluster randomised clinical trial to improve health outcomes among Argentine patients disengaged from HIV care · Lancet Reg Health Am (2022) · doi:10.1016/j.lana.2022.100307