Lung medicine · Eur Respir J · 2022
Summary: fewer hospital stays and deaths in 2020, not luck. Its own counts: could be luck.
How often chance alone would give a gap this big in heart-failure hospital stays
The paper says
In March and April 2020, Italian patients with high blood pressure in the lungs had fewer heart-failure hospital stays than a year earlier (1.2% vs 1.9%) and fewer non-COVID deaths (0.3% vs 0.5%). The summary: chance alone would do that under 1 time in 1,000.
Its own data show
Its own counts: 23 of 1,922 hospitalised in 2020, 36 of 1,967 in 2019; 6 vs 10 deaths. With the standard formulas the paper names, chance alone gives a gap this big about 1 time in 9 for stays, a third to half the time for deaths. No common method comes near 1 in 1,000.
Small counts bounce around even when nothing changes. The usual bar for ruling out luck is under 1 time in 20; 1 in 9 falls short. For under 1 in 1,000, 2019 would have needed 53 or more stays, not 36. Yet the paper credits the drop to remote contact with doctors and wants these patients prioritised for remote monitoring.