Paperonium

Brain injury · Brain · 2022

The summary: 10 years older, 11 times the odds of dying. Its own numbers: 2.7 times.

The summary1.104 × 10, outside the rangeIts own numbers1.104 × itself ten times11×2.7×1.594.571×2×5×10×20×age makes no difference
The summary1.104 × 10, outsidethe rangeIts own numbers1.104 × itselften times11×2.7×1.594.571×2×5×20×age makes no difference

Times the odds of dying if 10 years older; bar: range its data allow

The paper says

In 98 brain-injury patients in intensive care, the paper’s summary says being 10 years older made the odds of dying (deaths per survivor, not quite the same as the chance of dying) 11 times as high. Its main text and a chart repeat the 11.

Its own data show

The main-text sentence that repeats the 11 also says each extra year multiplies the odds by 1.10, range 1.05 to 1.16 (1.104 unrounded, in files published with the paper). Ten years means 1.104 multiplied by itself ten times: 2.7, range 1.59 to 4.57 (the yearly range done alike). The summary’s 11 is 1.104 × 10.

Each year multiplies the odds by 1.104, and each next year multiplies the result again, like interest: 10.4% a year grows to about 2.7 times in ten years. Adding ten 10.4% rises without stacking gives about 2 times; 11 would need 27% a year. The summary’s figure is four times too big; older patients are still at higher risk.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

A daily temperature rhythm in the human brain predicts survival after brain injury · Brain (2022) · doi:10.1093/brain/awab466