Paperonium

Lung cancer · Commun Biol · 2022

Summary: partway-changed cancer cells are stiffer than fully changed ones. The paper’s own measurements: softer.

The summarystiffer, by an amount it never givesThe paper’s own measurements420 softer on average−420−700−140−800 pascals−4000400800samepartway cells softerpartway cells stiffer
The summarystiffer, by anamount itnever givesThe paper’s ownmeasurements420 softeron average−420−700 to −140−1,000 pascals01,000samepartway cells softerpartway cells stiffer

Stiffness gap between partway and fully changed cells, in pascals

The paper says

In the lab, a signalling protein changes lung-cancer cells from compact, stay-put cells into loose, mobile ones like those that spread cancer. The summary says cells caught partway through this change are stiffer than fully changed ones.

Its own data show

A tiny probe pressed into cells measured stiffness before adding the protein, 14 hours after (partway) and 48 hours after (fully changed). Averages in the paper’s own spreadsheet, in pascals (higher = stiffer): 212, 560, 980. Partway cells are softer: 12 of the 13 tested sit below the fully changed average. The main text agrees.

A range is where the true gap very likely lies, allowing for the luck of which cells got measured. Partway cells average 420 pascals softer (980 minus 560), range 140 to 700 softer: no part of it is stiffer. The summary’s stated reason the work could aid the search for treatments against cancer’s spread is this reversed claim.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Statistical parametrization of cell cytoskeleton reveals lung cancer cytoskeletal phenotype with partial EMT signature · Commun Biol (2022) · doi:10.1038/s42003-022-03358-0