Brain imaging · Hum Brain Mapp · 2022
Children with ADHD have smaller frontal lobes, the paper says. Its own numbers: could be chance.
How often chance alone gives this gap with no real difference
The paper says
This brain-iron study also says, in its summary, that children with ADHD have smaller frontal lobes: 182.6 cubic centimetres on average, against 189.8 without. Its table says that with no real difference, chance would give a gap that big only 1 time in 125.
Its own data show
Children vary: a typical frontal lobe is about 25 cubic centimetres off its group’s average, far more than the 7.2 gap. Applying the paper’s stated check for comparing two averages to its table (53 children with ADHD, 49 without) gives about 1 time in 6. Nothing in the paper explains 1 in 125.
Even with no real difference, two groups differ a little by chance; “1 time in N” is how often they differ this much. The paper counts rarer than 1 in 20 as real; 1 in 6 is not. Its main finding, lower brain iron, is unaffected; its frontal-lobe claim, and the idea that low iron explains it, lose support.