Paperonium

Cardiology · Circulation · 2021

The paper says its trial was publicly recorded before starting. It was recorded 33 months after.

2015201620172018Volunteers joiningJun 2015 to around Jul 201833 monthsafter the first volunteer joinedBefore Jun 2015The paper saysrecorded before anyone joinedMar 2018First public record
Before Jun 2015The paper saysrecorded before anyone joinedVolunteers joiningJun 2015 to around Jul 201833 monthsafter the first volunteer joinedMar 2018First public record

When the trial was first publicly recorded, against when its volunteers joined

The paper says

A trial assigned 56 people with thickened heart muscle, at random, to a year of exercise or, for comparison, yoga. Exercise halved the muscle’s stiffness, the paper reports. It says the trial was publicly recorded on ClinicalTrials.gov before anyone joined: “registered prospectively”.

Its own data show

The trial’s ClinicalTrials.gov record dates the first volunteer’s joining to 1 June 2015 and its own first submission to 1 March 2018, 33 months later; the site keeps every past version, and none is older. Each volunteer took part for a year and the last finished in July 2019, so joining ended around July 2018.

Trials are supposed to post, on a public registry and before anyone joins, the main measurement they’ll be judged on, so it can’t be picked after results come in. Here the record’s measurement does match the paper’s, but with at least 33 of the roughly 37 joining months already gone, the record cannot show it was fixed in advance.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

One-Year Committed Exercise Training Reverses Abnormal Left Ventricular Myocardial Stiffness in Patients with Stage-B HFpEF · Circulation (2021) · doi:10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.121.054117