Cancer immunotherapy · Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A · 2022
Called “significant”; chance alone would produce this 1 time in 10. The bar: 1 in 20.
How often chance alone gives this gap if the three ways made no difference
The paper says
T cells (immune cells) are switched on before being given a new gene. The paper tried three ways; it says adding CD81 helps “naive” T cells (not yet exposed to their target) take up the gene: a “statistically significant difference” (P = 0.096).
Its own data show
With CD81, more naive cells did take up the gene. But P = 0.096 means even if the three ways made no real difference, chance alone would give a gap this big about 1 time in 10. This Figure 3 test is the paper’s only test of gene uptake, the outcome in its title.
By convention, a gap is “statistically significant” only if chance alone would produce one this big 1 time in 20 or more rarely (P of 0.05 or less). The paper names no cutoff; its Figure 2 uses the same words for P = 0.038, which passes. Figure 3’s 0.096 fails, so by that standard the gain is not significant.