Paperonium

Brain imaging · Hum Brain Mapp · 2020

Paper’s summary: three brain areas reliably smaller in people addicted to cannabis. Its own test: none.

The paper’s summary: “reliable reductions”3 of 7 areasThe paper’s own test, in its table0 of 7 areasEven with no adjustment2 of 7 areas0123
The paper’s summary:“reliable reductions”3 of 7 areasThe paper’s own test, in its table0 of 7 areasEven with no adjustment2 of 7 areas0123

Brain areas, out of seven checked, counted as smaller in people addicted to cannabis

The paper says

The paper pooled brain-scan studies comparing people addicted to cannabis with people who are not. Its summary says three areas deep in the brain (the hippocampus, amygdala and accumbens) show “reliable reductions” in size. Elsewhere the paper uses “reliable” to mean passing its test.

Its own data show

The paper’s results and conclusion say no area passes its rule: a size gap counts only if luck alone would produce one that big less than 1 time in 20, after adjusting for checking seven areas. Its table: hippocampus and amygdala 1 in 6, accumbens about 1 in 3, far more often, so all fail.

Check seven areas and one may differ by luck alone, so the paper sets a stricter bar for each. Even without that adjustment, only two areas pass, the hippocampus (1 in 42) and amygdala (1 in 22); the accumbens (1 in 5) fails. So “three” is wrong either way, in the part most people read.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

How do substance use disorders compare to other psychiatric conditions on structural brain abnormalities? A cross-disorder meta-analytic comparison using the ENIGMA consortium findings · Hum Brain Mapp (2020) · doi:10.1002/hbm.25114