Mental health · Psychol Med · 2021
The summary’s 4.5 lies outside its own range, 1.4 to 3.8. The table’s range reaches 13.8.
Times the odds of losing or changing a job, serious versus low distress
The paper says
The paper’s summary: adults who reported serious mental distress in a survey before the pandemic had 4.5 times the odds (chance it happens versus chance it doesn’t) of losing or changing a job during it, compared with low-distress adults. Plausible range: 1.4 to 3.8.
Its own data show
The paper’s table prints the same 4.5 with a range of 1.4 to 13.8. Ranges of this kind reach up by the same factor they reach down: 4.5 is about 3 times 1.4, so the top should be about 3 times 4.5, near 14. Only 13.8 fits; the main text repeats the summary’s error (3.75).
A range of plausible values spans what the data can’t rule out, so the result must sit inside it. The main finding holds: the range’s bottom, 1.4, is still above 1, which would mean no difference. But the effect is far less certain than the summary says: anywhere from 1.4 to nearly 14 times the odds.