Vaccines · Lancet Infect Dis · 2021
The Pfizer vaccine’s 71.4% for over-80s is right; the summary gives it an AstraZeneca result’s range.
Over-80s: how much one dose cut COVID-19 hospital admissions. Dot: result; bar: plausible range.
The paper says
The paper’s summary, the short overview at the top: in people aged 80 or over, one dose of the Pfizer vaccine cut the chance of being admitted to hospital with COVID-19 by 71.4%, with a range of 46.5% to 90.6%.
Its own data show
The 71.4% is right. But the paper’s detailed results, in its text and table, give it a range of 43.1% to 86.2%. The summary’s 46.5 to 90.6 matches, digit for digit, only one row of that table: AstraZeneca’s vaccine, in a simpler estimate (76.7%) made before allowing for differences between the people compared.
A range is the span of results the data plausibly fit; its low end is the least protection one dose plausibly gives. The summary, the most-read part, sets both ends too high (by 3.4 and 4.4 points), so the worst case looks better. An article printed alongside repeats the wrong range; no correction yet. The 71.4% and conclusion stand.