Paperonium

Brain science · J Neurosci · 2021

“Obesity cut insulin receptors on brain-cell surfaces.” The paper’s numbers fail its own 1-in-20 chance rule.

1 in 100every time1 in 20the usual barjust overabout1 in 22The paper’s resultsabout1 in 10Its own score, tested either way
1 in 100every time1 in 20the usual barjust overabout1 in 22The paper’s resultsabout1 in 10Its own score,tested either way

How often chance alone would give a gap this big if diet did nothing

The paper says

The paper’s summary says obesity cut insulin receptors (insulin’s docking points) on brain-cell surfaces. Its results: 21.7% fewer in fat-fed animals than normal-diet ones, p = 0.046: if diet did nothing, chance alone would give a gap this big about 1 time in 22.

Its own data show

The paper says it checked for a change either way, up or down. That gives chance two ways to make a gap, so p is twice a drop-only check’s. Its score, 1.75 (the gap measured against how much its 20 samples vary), gives 0.097 (1 in 10) either-way and 0.049 drop-only, near the printed 0.046.

The paper counts a gap as a finding only if chance alone would produce one that big less than 1 time in 20. At 1 in 10 it fails, unless the score or either-way label is wrong. The drop may be real, but the paper uses it to help explain why obesity blunts an effect of insulin on brain cells.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Insulin Bidirectionally Alters NAc Glutamatergic Transmission: Interactions between Insulin Receptor Activation, Endogenous Opioids, and Glutamate Release · J Neurosci (2021) · doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3216-18.2021