Paperonium

Amputation surgery · PNAS · 2021

The summary’s 12.47 vs 10.14 “degrees” of movement actually score how real a missing foot feels.

The summaryHow far the missing foot moves10.1412.47degrees515pointsStandard surgeryNew surgeryIts resultsHow real the missing foot feels
The summaryHow far the missing foot moves10.1412.47degrees515pointsStandard surgeryNew surgeryIts resultsHow real the missing foot feels

The same two numbers: what the summary calls them, and what they measure

The paper says

The paper compares two ways of amputating a leg below the knee. Afterwards, patients still feel the missing foot, and feel they can move it. The paper’s opening summary says the newer surgery’s patients could move it through a wider angle: 12.47 versus 10.14 degrees.

Its own data show

In the paper’s results and its table of every patient’s scores, 12.47 and 10.14 are average scores of how real the missing foot feels. Movement appears only as a percentage of the other, healthy ankle’s movement. There the new surgery did better, beyond what chance explains, for toes down, toes up and sole turned out.

A degree measures an angle. This score doesn’t: patients say how real five parts of the missing foot feel (ankle, heel, arch, ball, toes), graded 1 to 3 each, so totals run 5 to 15. The gap is 2.3 points. Anyone combining studies from their summaries would record 2.3 degrees more movement; the study never measured movement in degrees.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Neural interfacing architecture enables enhanced motor control and residual limb functionality postamputation · PNAS (2021) · doi:10.1073/pnas.2019555118