Child health · Kidney Int · 2021
The paper’s 8.4 extra hospital days lie outside its own range of 4.4 to 6.7 days.
Extra days in hospital with sudden kidney injury
The paper says
Of 152 children hospitalized with COVID-19 or a related inflammatory illness, those with sudden kidney injury stayed 8.4 days longer than those without, says the summary, with a range of 4.4 to 6.7 days. Its results and Table 4 print the same numbers.
Its own data show
This kind of range reaches equally far either side of its estimate, as most rows of its Table 4 do. But the middle of 4.4 to 6.7 is 5.55, so a printed number is wrong. If it is 8.4, the stay is about 5.6 days longer; if the top, the range is 4.4 to 12.4.
A range marks where the true value likely lies; a narrower one means a surer result. This is a main finding of the summary, and nothing in the paper says which number is wrong. Either way, kidney-injured children stayed clearly longer. But 5.6 days or 8.4? And is the range 2.3 days wide or 8.0, about 3.5 times as wide?