Paperonium

Brain injury · Neurology · 2021

Summary: 347 people had both the 1- and 5-year tests. Its own groups: 281.

347The summary: tested at both times66people too many281Its own groups: tested at both162Had a concussion119No concussion
347The summary: tested at both times66people too many281Its own groups: testedat both162Had a concussion119No concussion

People tested both 1 and 5 years after injury

The paper says

A study tested people who had a concussion in a war zone, and people who had not, on symptoms, mental health, and memory and thinking, 1 and 5 years after injury. Its summary says 347 people had both the 1-year and the 5-year tests.

Its own data show

The main text says 347 had the 1-year tests and 281 had both. Its own group counts agree: 136 + 26 = 162 with a concussion, 80 + 39 = 119 without, 281 in all. So the summary’s 347 is the 1-year count: 66 people, about 1 in 5, never had the 5-year tests.

Only people tested both times can show who got worse. People who don’t come back may differ from those who do: if the worst-off stopped coming, year 5 would look better than it is. The analyses use the right 281, but the summary’s figures on who got worse appear to cover 347, and it never says 1 in 5 left.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Comparison of Clinical Outcomes 1 and 5 Years Post-Injury Following Combat Concussion · Neurology (2021) · doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000011089