Paperonium

Stroke · Stroke · 2020

Summary: 2.45 times the odds of rehab, range 0.81 to 1.25. That range excludes 2.45.

Its table, before adjustingresult 2.19, range 0.75–6.38Summary and tableoutside its rangeIts own numbers, rebuilttop about 7.4, not 1.252.45×0.81 to 1.25should be inside0.810.5×1×2×5×10×COVID-19 makes no difference
Its table, beforeadjustingresult 2.19,range 0.75–6.38Summary and tableoutside its rangeshould be insideIts ownnumbers, rebuilttop about 7.4,not 1.252.45×0.81 to 1.250.810.3×1×3×10×COVID-19 makesno difference

Times the odds of leaving hospital for rehab, stroke patients with versus without COVID-19

The paper says

Stroke patients with COVID-19 had 2.45 times the odds (chance it happens over chance it doesn’t) of leaving hospital for rehab, versus those without. The range of values the data can’t rule out: 0.81 to 1.25. The summary, results and a table all print this.

Its own data show

Before adjusting, the same table gives 2.19, range 0.75 to 6.38: its ends sit the same multiple below and above 2.19, as they should. Rebuilt that way from 2.45 and its bottom end, 0.81, the adjusted range tops out at about 7.4. The printed top, 1.25, is below 2.45 itself.

A range’s width shows how sure a result is. Printed, this one is narrow and hugs 1 (no difference). Rebuilt, it runs from 0.81 to about 7.4: wide, as expected when only 22 stroke patients had COVID-19. Both include 1, so no difference stays possible; but the printed range makes this small study look far surer than it is.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Ischemic Stroke Occurs Less Frequently in Patients With COVID-19 · Stroke (2020) · doi:10.1161/STROKEAHA.120.031217