Paperonium

Wetlands and climate · Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci · 2020

A study says drought “stopped” a wetland’s CO2 emissions. Its own totals say it kept emitting.

Years before the drought, average+0.34, emittingThe stated balance, 2018−0.03, emissions “stopped”Its own totals, 2018+0.16 (3.88 − 3.72), still emitting−0.100.10.20.30.4kg CO2 per square metre a year
Years before thedrought, average+0.34, emittingThe statedbalance, 2018−0.03,emissions “stopped”Its own totals, 2018+0.16(3.88 − 3.72),still emitting−0.100.10.20.30.4kg CO2 per square metre a year

Yearly CO2 balance, given off minus absorbed, kg per m²; above zero means emitting

The paper says

A wetland’s yearly CO2 balance is what it gives off minus what its plants absorb. It had averaged +0.34 kg per square metre: emitting. The summary says the 2018 drought “stopped” this; the results put 2018 at −0.03, slightly more absorbed than given off.

Its own data show

By the paper’s own definition, the balance is simply one yearly total minus the other. Its 2018 totals: 3.88 kg per square metre given off, 3.72 absorbed. 3.88 − 3.72 = +0.16: still emitting, about half the earlier +0.34. Its chart of these totals building up over the year (Figure 3) shows the same gap.

A balance is just one total minus the other, like a bank balance. It works for the other wetland the paper studied: 3.19 given off − 3.58 absorbed = −0.39, as stated. Here it misses by 0.19, over half the earlier yearly emissions. The numbers can’t all be right; if the totals are, drought halved emissions rather than stopping them.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

The impact of occasional drought periods on vegetation spread and greenhouse gas exchange in rewetted fens · Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci (2020) · doi:10.1098/rstb.2019.0685