Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Zarnekow fen 2018 CO2 components imply a net source; the paper reports a net sink

Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci (2020) Β· doi:10.1098/rstb.2019.0685 Β· PMC7485093

Summary

The paper reports eddy-covariance CO2 budgets for two rewetted fens, HΓΌtelmoor (Hte) and Zarnekow (Zrk), during the 2018 drought and the year after. Its Abstract states that the drought "stopped the persistent net CO2 emissions of Zrk", which rests on a reported 2018 net balance (NEE) of βˆ’0.03 kg CO2 m⁻², a small net sink. The paper defines NEE as the sum of gross ecosystem productivity (GEP, negative) and ecosystem respiration (Reco), and its own Zrk 2018 sums give 3.88 βˆ’ 3.72 = +0.16 kg CO2 m⁻², a net source. The Zrk 2019 sums do not add up either (+0.33 against a reported +0.06), while the Hte budget closes exactly, and the curves in Figure 3 show the same mismatch as the text. So the reported Zrk numbers cannot all be right, and which ones are wrong decides whether Zrk was a sink or a source in 2018, and how much its emissions fell in 2019.

What the paper reports

Abstract:

Altogether, the drought reduced the net CO2 sink in Hte, while it stopped the persistent net CO2 emissions of Zrk.

Methods, "Data acquisition" (the definitions that link the three quantities):

The measured net ecosystem exchange of CO2 (NEE) was partitioned into the two opposed component fluxes gross ecosystem productivity (GEP, here indicated with a negative sign) and ecosystem respiration (Reco) by modelling. Reco, the CO2 released by autotrophic and heterotrophic respiration into the atmosphere, was obtained from night-time NEE fluxes. GEP, the photosynthetic sequestration of CO2 from the atmosphere into the canopy, was then calculated from the difference between NEE and Reco.

Results, "Drought effects on carbon dioxide and methane exchange", first paragraph:

The summer drought 2018 caused new maxima in annual GEP sums of 3.58 and 3.72 kg CO2 m-2 in Hte and Zrk (figure 3a,b). These exceeded the average annual GEP totals of the reference years 2014–2017 by 22 and 86%, respectively.

GEP in Zrk, on the other hand, remained high in 2019, reaching annual sums of 3.39 kg m-2.

Same section, second paragraph:

The warm and dry conditions in 2018 also induced new maxima in the annual Reco sums, which amounted to 3.19 and 3.88 kg CO2 m-2 in Hte and Zrk (figure 3c,d). This corresponded to an increase of 35 and 56%, respectively, in comparison to reference years.

In Zrk, Reco remained at the same level in 2019 (3.72 kg CO2 m-2).

Same section, third paragraph (the net balances):

In Hte, the resulting net CO2 balance amounted to -0.39 kg CO2 m-2. Hence, Hte remained a CO2 sink though net CO2 uptake was 0.18 kg m-2 lower than in previous years (figure 3e). In Zrk, photosynthetic CO2 sequestration almost doubled in 2018 and thereby offset respiratory CO2 losses by 0.03 kg CO2 m-2 (figure 3f). Indeed, net CO2 uptake was comparatively low, but the fen had previously acted as a net CO2 source with average NEE balances of +0.34 kg CO2 m-2 [14]. In 2019, Zrk became a net CO2 source of 0.06 kg m-2 again, though CO2 emissions were considerably lower than in the years before the drought.

Same section, last paragraph:

In addition, the year after the drought revealed marked carry-over effects in Zrk: here, the newly formed vegetation persisted under climate-normal conditions with beneficial consequences for GEP and the net CO2 balance.

Figure 3 caption (excerpt):

Cumulative fluxes of CO2 and CH4 for the year of drought 2018, the post-drought year 2019 and the reference period 2014–2017. Negative signs indicate CO2 uptake from the atmosphere into the ecosystem.

Conclusion:

The drought-induced spread in vegetation can increase photosynthetic CO2 sequestration and thereby move the net CO2 budget closer towards a sink.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. With GEP negative, the Methods' definition "GEP … calculated from the difference between NEE and Reco" means GEP = NEE βˆ’ Reco, so annual NEE = GEP + Reco = Reco βˆ’ |GEP|. I applied this identity to every site-year for which the text gives all three annual sums, and used Hte as a control. Each value is printed to 0.01, so rounding can move GEP + Reco βˆ’ NEE by at most 3 Γ— 0.005 = 0.015. I also back-calculated the reference-period (2014–2017) means implied by the stated percentage increases. To check whether the text matches the figure, I read the end-of-year values of the cumulative GEP, Reco and NEE curves in Figure 3 from the publisher's image (PMC open-access copy, rstb20190685-g3.jpg). I calibrated each panel's y axis from its tick marks and recorded the pixel row of each curve at its last drawn column. One pixel is 0.017 (GEP), 0.019 (Reco) and 0.009 (NEE) kg CO2 m⁻², so the summed reading error is about Β±0.045. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt. Units are kg CO2 m⁻² yr⁻¹, and negative values mean net uptake.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from the paper's numbers
Hte 2018 NEE (control) Results, 3rd para.; Fig. 3a,c,e GEP βˆ’3.58, Reco 3.19, NEE βˆ’0.39 3.19 βˆ’ 3.58 = βˆ’0.39; closes exactly
Hte 2018 drop in uptake vs reference (control) Results, 3rd para. 0.18 lower reference NEE βˆ’0.571 (from +22% and +35%), so 0.181 lower; consistent
Zrk 2018 NEE Results, 1st–3rd para.; Fig. 3b,d,f; Abstract GEP βˆ’3.72, Reco 3.88, NEE βˆ’0.03 (sink) 3.88 βˆ’ 3.72 = +0.16 (source); gap +0.19
Zrk 2018, rounding range derived β€” GEP + Reco between +0.15 and +0.17; cannot round to βˆ’0.03
Zrk 2018, value needed to give NEE βˆ’0.03 derived Reco 3.88 or GEP βˆ’3.72 Reco 3.69 (with GEP βˆ’3.72), or GEP βˆ’3.91 (with Reco 3.88)
Zrk 2019 NEE Results, 1st–3rd para. GEP βˆ’3.39, Reco 3.72, NEE +0.06 3.72 βˆ’ 3.39 = +0.33; gap +0.27
Zrk 2019, rounding range derived β€” +0.32 to +0.34
Zrk 2019, value needed to give NEE +0.06 derived Reco 3.72 or GEP βˆ’3.39 Reco 3.45 (with GEP βˆ’3.39), or GEP βˆ’3.66 (with Reco 3.72)
Zrk reference GEP and Reco implied by +86% and +56% Results, 1st–2nd para. "almost doubled" reference |GEP| 2.000, reference Reco 2.487; 2018 GEP is Γ—1.86 (consistent with "almost doubled")
Zrk reference NEE implied by the percentages derived +0.34 (cited from ref. [14]) +0.487; ref. [14] was published in 2016, so its period cannot be the full 2014–2017 reference
Zrk 2018 Reco if the reference NEE were +0.34 derived 3.88 (+56%) reference Reco 2.340, so +56% gives 3.65, and 3.88 would be +66%
Figure 3 end-of-year values, Hte 2018 Fig. 3a,c,e β€” GEP βˆ’3.59, Reco +3.18, sum βˆ’0.41; NEE curve βˆ’0.41; non-closure 0.00
Figure 3 end-of-year values, Hte 2019 Fig. 3a,c,e GEP βˆ’2.56 (text) GEP βˆ’2.56, Reco +2.40, sum βˆ’0.16; NEE curve βˆ’0.14; non-closure βˆ’0.02
Figure 3 end-of-year values, Zrk 2018 Fig. 3b,d,f GEP βˆ’3.72, Reco 3.88, NEE βˆ’0.03 GEP βˆ’3.71, Reco +3.87, sum +0.16; NEE curve βˆ’0.03; non-closure +0.19
Figure 3 end-of-year values, Zrk 2019 Fig. 3b,d,f GEP βˆ’3.39, Reco 3.72, NEE +0.06 GEP βˆ’3.39, Reco +3.70, sum +0.32; NEE curve +0.04; non-closure +0.28
Zrk 2019 vs the earlier average of +0.34 Results, 3rd para. "considerably lower" stated +0.06 is 0.28 lower; GEP + Reco +0.33 is 0.01 lower (0.16 lower than the percentage-implied reference +0.49)

The 2019 dashed curves in Figure 3 end about one to two weeks before 31 December, so the 2019 readings are slightly early. The Zrk 2019 NEE curve is still rising at that point, which is why it reads +0.04 rather than the stated +0.06.

The Hte budget closes to within 0.02: in 2018 in both the text and the figure, and in 2019 in the figure (the text gives no 2019 Hte Reco or NEE). The Zrk budget fails to close by about 0.2 to 0.3 kg CO2 m⁻² in both years, and Figure 3 reproduces the same mismatch as the text. The mismatch is therefore not a misprint in one sentence: the cumulative Zrk GEP and Reco curves, as drawn, do not add up to the Zrk NEE curve drawn below them.

Figure

Stated annual NEE versus Reco βˆ’ |GEP| from the paper's stated sums, per site-year

Figure 1. For each site-year in which the text states all three annual sums, the orange dot is the net CO2 balance (NEE) stated in the paper. The blue dot is Reco βˆ’ |GEP| computed from the GEP and Reco sums stated in the same section. The vertical black line at zero separates a net sink (left) from a net source (right). The dotted line is the earlier Zrk average of +0.34 kg CO2 m⁻² that the paper cites from ref. [14]. For Hte 2018 the two values coincide (βˆ’0.39), so the paper's identity holds there. For Zrk 2018 the stated βˆ’0.03 is a small sink, but the stated components give +0.16, a source. For Zrk 2019 the stated +0.06 is well below the earlier average, but the stated components give +0.33, close to it.

Non-closure of the annual CO2 budget, from the text and from the Figure 3 curves

Figure 2. The non-closure GEP + Reco βˆ’ NEE for each site-year, which is zero when the budget adds up. Filled blue dots use the annual sums stated in the text, where all three are given. Hollow blue dots use the end-of-year values read from the cumulative curves of the paper's Figure 3, with a Β±1-pixel reading error on each curve, summed over the three. The grey band marks Β±0.015, the most that rounding to two decimals can explain. Hte closes in both years. Zrk misses by +0.19 (2018) and +0.27 to +0.28 (2019), and the text and the figure agree on this.

Why it matters

The Zrk 2018 result is one of the paper's two headline CO2 findings. The Abstract says the drought "stopped the persistent net CO2 emissions of Zrk", and the Results say the GEP gain "offset respiratory CO2 losses by 0.03 kg CO2 m-2". These statements hold only if the stated NEE of βˆ’0.03 is the correct annual balance. If the stated GEP and Reco sums are correct, Zrk stayed a net CO2 source in 2018 (+0.16), although a weaker one than the +0.34 the paper cites for earlier years. The 0.19 difference changes the sign of the balance, and so whether the drought "stopped" Zrk's emissions or only reduced them.

The 2019 statement is affected by more. The paper says Zrk "became a net CO2 source of 0.06 kg m-2 again, though CO2 emissions were considerably lower than in the years before the drought", and describes "beneficial consequences for GEP and the net CO2 balance" as a carry-over effect. With the stated 2019 components (+0.33), the 2019 balance is almost equal to the cited earlier average of +0.34. Compared with the reference implied by the paper's own percentages (+0.49), it is still 0.16 lower. Which Zrk numbers are correct therefore decides whether there is a post-drought reduction in net emissions at Zrk, and how large it is.

The direction of the broader conclusion is not affected. Both candidate 2018 values (βˆ’0.03 and +0.16) lie below the earlier Zrk average, so the drought moved the Zrk budget "closer towards a sink", as the Conclusion says. The Hte results, the GEP and Reco percentage changes and the CH4 results are not affected.

Explanations considered

Status

Suggested correction

  1. Recheck the Zrk annual sums for 2018 and 2019 (GEP, Reco and NEE in the Results text and the cumulative curves in Figure 3b, d and f), and publish a consistent set. If the components are correct, the 2018 balance is about +0.16 and the 2019 balance about +0.33 kg CO2 m⁻²; if NEE is correct, Reco or GEP must change, for example Reco β‰ˆ 3.69 in 2018 and β‰ˆ 3.45 in 2019 at the stated GEP.
  2. If the non-closure is a real result of gap-filling NEE separately from the modelled Reco and GEP, state that in the Methods and the Figure 3 legend. Report its size for each site-year, say which quantity is used as the annual net balance, and explain why it is preferred.
  3. Revise the Abstract and Results statements that depend on the Zrk balance accordingly: "it stopped the persistent net CO2 emissions of Zrk", "offset respiratory CO2 losses by 0.03 kg CO2 m-2", and the 2019 statement that emissions "were considerably lower than in the years before the drought".
  4. State the period and value of the pre-drought Zrk NEE used as the comparison. The cited +0.34 (ref. [14]) differs from the +0.49 implied by the stated percentage increases over 2014–2017.