Paperonium

Brain injury · Brain · 2018

One paragraph says top-of-brain damage cut veterans’ giving. The paper’s results say it raised giving.

Top of the brainResults and summariesraised givinggiving unchangedOne paragraphdamage cut givingBehind the right earOne paragraphdamage raised givingResults and summariescut giving
Top of the brainResults and summariesraised givinggiving unchangedOne paragraphdamage cut givingBehind the right earOne paragraphdamage raised givingResults and summariescut giving

Did damage to each region raise or cut giving?

The paper says

94 veterans with brain injuries each had 30 chances to give away $1. One paragraph says top-of-brain damage cut their giving and damage behind the right ear raised it, and closes by suggesting the top of the brain helps people give.

Its own data show

The results section says the reverse: top-of-brain damage raised giving and damage behind the right ear cut it. So do the paper’s summary, a later recap of its main findings, and the brain-map figure’s colour key, read against the colours on its maps. Only that figure’s colour scale, read literally, sides with the paragraph.

Brain-injury studies learn what a region does from what its damage changes: if damage makes people give more, the healthy region is taken to hold giving back. So the results imply the top of the brain restrains giving; the paragraph ends by suggesting it helps. This is one of the paper’s two main findings; no correction has been published.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Altruistic decisions following penetrating traumatic brain injury · Brain (2018) · doi:10.1093/brain/awy064