Paperonium

Neurology · Curr Biol · 2020

One sentence swaps two labels, so stimulation that cut tics 31% appears to raise them 44%.

One sentenceIts spreadsheet126.3With stimulation87.6With stimulation87.6Without stimulation126.3Without stimulationChange with stimulationOne sentence:up 44% by its numbersIts spreadsheet:down 31%
One sentenceIts spreadsheet126.3With stimulation87.6With stimulation87.6Withoutstimulation126.3WithoutstimulationChange with stimulationOne sentence:up 44% by its numbersIts spreadsheet:down 31%

Average tics per person over 4 minutes, without and with stimulation

The paper says

Tourette syndrome causes tics: repeated movements or sounds. The paper says rhythmic pulses to a nerve in the arm cut tics in 16 people. Yet one sentence stating this gives average tics over 4 minutes as 87.6 without stimulation and 126.3 with it: a rise.

Its own data show

Only that sentence is backwards. A spreadsheet of each person’s counts, published with the paper, gives the same two averages the right way round: 126.3 without stimulation, 87.6 with it, a 31% drop; 12 of 16 people had fewer tics with it. The paper’s opening summary, its figure and its discussion also show a drop.

A percentage change is measured from the starting number: 126.3 falling to 87.6 is a drop of 38.7, or 31% of 126.3; 87.6 rising to 126.3 is the same 38.7, but 44% of 87.6. The paper’s conclusion stands, but anyone copying these two averages into a review pooling many tic studies would record that stimulation raised tics by 44%.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Entraining Movement-Related Brain Oscillations to Suppress Tics in Tourette Syndrome · Curr Biol (2020) · doi:10.1016/j.cub.2020.04.044