Neuroscience · eLife · 2019
Paper: chance gives this change 1 time in 42. Its own score means 1 in 10.
How often chance alone would cause a change this big in the cells’ activity
The paper says
A drug cut the electrical activity of brain cells from rats less motivated by reward, but not clearly in more motivated rats’ cells. For the less motivated rats, the paper says, chance alone would cause a change that big only 1 time in 42.
Its own data show
Figure 5’s caption prints the test score behind it: 3.7, from 7 cells. That works out to about 1 in 10, missing the paper’s bar for a real effect: rarer than 1 in 20. Getting 1 in 42 needs a score near 9. The more motivated rats’ score, 0.99, gives their printed 36 in 100.
The test condenses the cells’ changes into one score, and the cell count fixes which chance figure each score gives. So one number is wrong. If the 1 in 42 is wrong, neither group clearly responds, and the claim that only one does loses its key test, though others lean that way. If the 3.7 is wrong, the claim holds.