Paperonium

Pancreas disease · Gut · 2018

Trial promised to count fix-up procedures within 6 weeks; its paper silently counted all procedures instead.

The public plan2016, still the same in 2019The paper2018, no mention of the changeMain measureMissingFix-ups within 6 weeksAll procedures over 6 monthstypically metal 2 vs plastic 3All procedures over 6 monthsnot listedFix-ups within 6 weeksnever mentioned
The public plan2016, still thesame in 2019The paper2018, no mentionof the changeMainmeasureMissingFix-upswithin 6 weeksAll proceduresover 6 monthstypically metal 2vs plastic 3All proceduresover 6 monthsnot listedFix-upswithin 6 weeksnever mentioned

Each measure’s place in the trial’s public plan and in the paper

The paper says

Metal or plastic tubes drain dead tissue left by an inflamed pancreas. Main result: over 6 months, the typical metal-tube patient had 2 procedures, plastic 3, a gap luck could explain. Everyone’s count starts at 2: placing the tube and a planned 6-week camera check.

Its own data show

The trial’s plan, posted on ClinicalTrials.gov, a public registry, counts only fix-ups within 6 weeks: extra procedures because the patient isn’t recovering well after the first tube. The paper never mentions this measure. Its totals: 8 fix-ups among 31 metal patients, 16 among 29 plastic, never split at 6 weeks or checked against luck.

A trial is judged on one main result, and posts in advance what it will count, so readers can check nothing was swapped after the data came in. The paper’s count adds the 2 procedures everyone had, plus treatments for complications (14 metal, 3 plastic), which the plan excluded. Whether metal needs fewer fix-ups, the promised question, goes unanswered.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Non-superiority of lumen-apposing metal stents over plastic stents for drainage of walled-off necrosis in a randomised trial · Gut (2018) · doi:10.1136/gutjnl-2017-315335