Meningitis genetics · Nat Commun · 2019
Summary: genes explain “almost half” of who gets meningitis, “one-third” of severity. Results: the reverse.
Genes’ share of the differences between people: the summary’s words vs the paper’s results
The paper says
Pneumococcal meningitis is an infection of the brain’s lining caused by one kind of bacterium, the pneumococcus. The paper’s summary (the short overview at the top) says differences in people’s genes explain “almost half” of who gets it and “one-third” of how severe it gets.
Its own data show
The paper’s results give the reverse: genes explain 29% of who gets it and 49% of how severe meningitis gets; its discussion repeats both. A second method in its table gives 25% for who gets it, also far from half, and 29% for severity. Severity counts meningitis from any germ.
“Genes explain 29%” means: of all the differences between people in who gets the disease, 29% trace back to the gene differences the study measured. The summary, the part most readers see, says almost half; no calculation in the paper comes close. Its “one-third” for severity is near only the second method’s 29%; the paper reports 49%.