Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Abstract says host genetics explains almost half of meningitis susceptibility; the paper estimates 29%

Nat Commun (2019) · doi:10.1038/s41467-019-09976-3 · PMC6520353

Summary

The abstract states that human genetic variation "explains almost half of variation in susceptibility to pneumococcal meningitis and one-third of variation in severity". Table 4 gives 0.25 (GCTA) and 0.29 (LDAK) for susceptibility and 0.29 (GCTA) and 0.49 (LDAK) for severity; the Results and the Discussion quote only the LDAK values, as 29% ± 7% for susceptibility and 49% ± 14% for severity (the Discussion gives the severity error as ± 9%). No susceptibility estimate in the paper is near one half: 0.5 lies outside both recomputed susceptibility 95% confidence intervals. The abstract's two magnitudes match the body's headline values only if the phenotypes are swapped. The abstract also implies that host genetics matters more for susceptibility than for severity, while the paper's headline estimates rank them the other way. The significance of either estimate is unaffected, and so are the paper's other findings.

What the paper reports

Abstract:

In a genome-wide association study of human and pathogen we show that human variation explains almost half of variation in susceptibility to pneumococcal meningitis and one-third of variation in severity, identifying variants in CCDC33 associated with susceptibility.

Results, "Human genetics associates with susceptibility and severity", paragraph 3:

We then used two standard methods to calculate SNP heritability, which both showed that variation in host genetics explains 29% ± 7% of the observed variation in pneumococcal meningitis susceptibility and 49% ± 14% of the variation in meningitis severity (Table 4).

Discussion, paragraph 2:

Host genetics explained 29% ± 7% of variation in susceptibility to meningitis.

We found no evidence for pathogen genetics affecting the severity of disease, whereas human genetics explained 49% ± 9% of this variation.

Table 4, "Human SNP heritability (h2SNP) of meningitis in the MeninGene cohort" (columns: Phenotype | Method | Heritability | Error | p-value):

Susceptibility (pneumococcal) | GCTA | 0.25 | 0.05 | 2.4 × 10–6

Susceptibility (pneumococcal) | LDAK | 0.29 | 0.07 | 3.9 × 10–6

Severity (any species) | GCTA | 0.29 | 0.11 | 2.8 × 10–5

Severity (any species) | LDAK | 0.49 | 0.14 | 1.4 × 10–4

Table 4 footer:

Heritabilities are shown on the liability scale (adjusted for population prevalence and case ascertainment ratio).

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. The abstract gives words, not numbers, so I read "almost half" as about 0.50 and "one-third" as 0.333. I compared each with both Table 4 estimates for the same phenotype. I built 95% confidence intervals as estimate ± 1.96 × the Table 4 "Error" column, treating that column as a standard error, and checked whether each interval contains 0.5 or 1/3. I also checked that the Results and Discussion percentages match the Table 4 rows. Finally I tested whether the two LDAK estimates differ from each other, with a z-test that treats them as independent. That is an approximation: the two phenotypes share control samples, so the estimates are not strictly independent. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from the paper's numbers
Host h² for susceptibility Abstract "almost half" (≈ 0.50) Table 4 gives 0.25 (GCTA) and 0.29 (LDAK). The nearest is 0.21 below 0.50
Host h² for severity Abstract "one-third" (≈ 0.33) Table 4 gives 0.29 (GCTA, 0.04 away) and 0.49 (LDAK, 0.16 away). The text's headline value is 0.49
Susceptibility, GCTA Table 4 0.25 ± 0.05 95% CI 0.152–0.348, which excludes 0.5
Susceptibility, LDAK Table 4; Results p3; Discussion p2 0.29 ± 0.07; "29% ± 7%" Text matches the table. 95% CI 0.153–0.427, which excludes 0.5
Severity, GCTA Table 4 0.29 ± 0.11 95% CI 0.074–0.506
Severity, LDAK Table 4; Results p3 0.49 ± 0.14; "49% ± 14%" Text matches the table. 95% CI 0.216–0.764
Abstract reading vs headline value, susceptibility Abstract vs Results p3 ≈ 0.50 vs 0.29 21.0 percentage points higher, 1.72 times the paper's estimate
Abstract reading vs headline value, severity Abstract vs Results p3 ≈ 0.33 vs 0.49 15.7 percentage points lower
Value nearest to "almost half" anywhere in Table 4 Table 4 — Severity, LDAK, 0.49 (0.01 from 0.50)
Severity minus susceptibility, LDAK Table 4 0.49 − 0.29 Difference 0.20, SE 0.157, z = 1.28, two-sided p = 0.20 (GCTA: 0.04, z = 0.33, p = 0.74)
Severity error Discussion p2 "49% ± 9%" Table 4 and the Results give ± 14%. With ± 9% the interval would be 0.314–0.666

The arithmetic in the body is internally consistent: the Results and Discussion quote the LDAK rows of Table 4. The inconsistency is between the abstract and everything else. For susceptibility no estimator in the paper gives a value near one half. For severity, "one-third" is close to the GCTA estimate (0.29), but the paper presents the LDAK estimate (0.49) as its headline severity figure in both the Results and the Discussion. Read together, the abstract's two magnitudes match the body's headline values (29% and 49%) with the phenotypes swapped.

Figure

The abstract's wording and the Results/Table 4 headline heritabilities, side by side

Figure 1. On the left is the abstract sentence. On the right is the Results sentence that cites Table 4 (verbatim excerpts). Below each are the values each passage gives for the same two phenotypes. Orange diamonds mark the abstract's words read as fractions. Blue dots mark the Table 4 LDAK estimates quoted in the Results. For susceptibility, the abstract's "almost half" (≈ 0.50) conflicts with 0.29 ± 0.07, and 0.5 is outside both recomputed susceptibility 95% confidence intervals. For severity, the abstract's "one-third" (≈ 0.33) sits below the headline 0.49 ± 0.14, although it is close to the GCTA estimate of 0.29. All values are host SNP heritability on the liability scale.

Table 4 heritability estimates with recomputed 95% confidence intervals, and the abstract's wording, on one axis

Figure 2. All four Table 4 estimates (blue dots) with 95% confidence intervals recomputed as ± 1.96 × the printed error, on one heritability axis that starts at zero (no heritability). The orange vertical marks show where the abstract's words fall for each phenotype. The susceptibility mark at 0.5 lies to the right of both susceptibility intervals. The severity mark at 1/3 lies inside both severity intervals. The intervals are wide, so the severity wording is not ruled out statistically, but it does not match the value the paper reports as its headline severity estimate.

Why it matters

The abstract is the part of the paper most readers see, and the host-heritability sentence is its main quantitative claim about human genetics. As written it overstates the host contribution to susceptibility by about 20 percentage points (≈ 0.50 against 0.29) and understates the headline severity estimate (≈ 0.33 against 0.49). It also reverses the order of the two phenotypes. The abstract suggests that host genetics matters more for susceptibility, while the paper's headline estimates suggest the opposite. Because the two estimates are not significantly different (z = 1.28, p = 0.20 under an independence approximation), the reversal matters less for the substance than for how the result is described. Anyone who cites the abstract's figures, for example in a review comparing heritability across infectious diseases, would carry forward a susceptibility value the paper does not support.

What the discrepancy does not affect: both host estimates remain significantly above zero (Table 4 p-values 3.9 × 10–6 and 1.4 × 10–4 for LDAK). The pathogen heritability results (70% for invasiveness, 0% for severity) are reported separately and correctly. The CCDC33, UBE2U, pspC and zmpD findings and the vaccine-target discussion are not affected.

Explanations considered

Status

As of 2026-10-23:

Sources: PMC6520353; publisher version; Crossref record; Europe PMC; bioRxiv preprint.

Suggested correction

Bring the abstract into line with Table 4 and the Results, for example:

… we show that human variation explains around 30% of variation in susceptibility to pneumococcal meningitis and almost half of variation in severity, …

If the authors prefer to describe severity by the GCTA estimate (0.29), the abstract should say so and give the same order of magnitude for both phenotypes ("around 30%"). In that case the Results and Discussion, which present 49% as the severity figure, would also need to change. Separately, the Discussion's "49% ± 9%" should read "49% ± 14%" to match Table 4 and the Results.