Plant ecology · Commun Biol · 2019
Summary: the weight of tree and shrub leaves rose 20%. The paper’s own totals show 50%.
Rise in the total weight of tree and shrub leaves, 1992 to 2012
The paper says
The paper’s summary says that across most of the Sahel (the dry belt south of the Sahara), estimates made from satellite measurements show the total weight of tree and shrub leaves rose 20%, and that of grasses and other small plants 6%.
Its own data show
Its results section repeats the 20% in the same sentence that gives the totals behind it, for the western and central Sahel: tree and shrub leaves went from 0.16 billion tonnes in 1992 to 0.24 in 2012, a 50% rise. Grasses went from 0.28 to 0.31 billion tonnes: 11%, not 6%.
A percentage rise is the gain divided by the starting amount: (0.24 − 0.16) ÷ 0.16 = 50%. The paper calls its 20% a “relative increase”, which normally means this. Even if 0.16 and 0.24 were rounded from 0.165 and 0.235, the rise is 42%. Trees and shrubs still outgrew grasses, but anyone quoting the summary gets 20%, not 50%.