Paperonium

Child development · Am J Epidemiol · 2018

Summary: born-small boys’ setbacks reliably exceed girls’ on all three measures. Its table: only on one.

The summary: all 3 reach 1 in 20Height, its own table1 in 16, falls shortWeight, its own table1 in 17, falls shortDevelopment, its own table1 in 23, passes0510152025
The summary: all 3 reach 1 in 20Height, its own table1 in 16, falls shortWeight, its own table1 in 17, falls shortDevelopment,its own table1 in 23, passes0510152025

How rarely chance alone gives a gap this big between boys’ and girls’ setbacks

The paper says

The opening summary says Brazilian babies born small for their stage of pregnancy scored lower at age 1 than normal-size babies on height, weight and development, a setback bigger in boys than girls by margins chance alone would give under 1 time in 20.

Its own data show

Further in, the paper’s own results table gives those boy-girl gaps p = 0.063 for height, 0.059 for weight and 0.043 for development: about 1 time in 16, 17 and 23. Only development is rarer than 1 in 20. The paper’s own text grades height and weight only against a looser 1-in-10 mark.

A p-value is how often chance alone would give a boy-girl gap this big if both sexes were hit equally. Rarer is stronger: 1 in 16 falls short of 1 in 20. These tests are the paper’s main evidence that boys may be more vulnerable. Boys’ height and weight setbacks were still over twice girls’; the summary overstates the certainty.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Overall and Sex-Specific Associations Between Fetal Adversity and Child Development at Age 1 Year: Evidence From Brazil · Am J Epidemiol (2018) · doi:10.1093/aje/kwy141