Paperonium

Eye research · J Neurosci · 2018

“Significantly” fewer dying eye cells, says the paper. By its own rule, that could be chance.

1 in 100every time1 in 20the usual barrarer than1 in 20The figure note: “significantly less”about1 in 15Its own result: fails the rule
1 in 100every time1 in 20the usual barrarer than1 in 20The figure note:“significantly less”about1 in 15Its own result:fails the rule

How often chance alone gives this gap if the gene made no difference

The paper says

When the retina, the eye’s light-sensing layer, comes loose, its light-detecting cells die. The paper’s summary leads with this: a day later, mice lacking one gene had about half as many dying cells as normal mice. A note under a figure calls it “significantly less.”

Its own data show

The paper’s methods set one rule: a difference counts as “significant” only if its p-value is below 0.05. Beside “significantly less”, the figure note prints p = 0.067. That fails the rule, and the paper makes no exception. Of the 16 exact p-values the paper prints, this is the only one above 0.05.

A p-value is how often chance alone would produce a gap this big if the gene made no difference. The paper’s bar is 1 time in 20; this result is about 1 in 15. So by its own rule, the summary’s lead finding could be chance, though other experiments in the paper point the same way.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Retinal Detachment-Induced Müller Glial Cell Swelling Activates TRPV4 Ion Channels and Triggers Photoreceptor Death at Body Temperature · J Neurosci (2018) · doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0897-18.2018