Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

The abstract names the inhibited RNA strand as negative, but the paper's own data show positive

Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A (2018) Β· doi:10.1073/pnas.1805195115 Β· PMC6176606

Summary

The paper studies a dengue virus genome carrying an NS3-G459L mutation that blocks an internal self-cleavage and acts as a trans-dominant inhibitor of wild-type virus in the same cell. The abstract states that this variant "dominantly inhibited negative-strand RNA synthesis." The Results section, using strand-specific RT-qPCR (Fig. 5 F and G), reports the opposite direction: positive-strand synthesis was strongly inhibited, while negative-strand synthesis was allowed (negative-strand RNA was significantly greater than the polymerase-dead control). The Results conclusion and the Discussion both state that positive-strand synthesis is the inhibited step. The single word "negative-strand" in the abstract therefore reverses the direction of the paper's key mechanistic result, and should read "positive-strand."

What the paper reports

an NS3-G459L variant that is incapable of cleavage at the internal NS3 junction dominantly inhibited negative-strand RNA synthesis of wild-type virus present in the same cell

β€” Abstract

To identify whether the dominant NS3-G459L mutant genome inhibited negative-strand synthesis (and therefore positive-strand synthesis as well) or just positive-strand synthesis, we performed strand-specific RT-qPCR to measure both strands of WT and GDD replicons (Fig. 5 F and G). ... The amount of positive-strand replicon RNA detected when cotransfected with the NS3-G459L dominant mutant was indistinguishable from that detected for the GDD replicon alone, indicating that positive-strand synthesis was strongly inhibited (Fig. 5F). By contrast, the amount of negative-strand replicon RNA was significantly greater than that for the GDD replicon alone (Fig. 5G), indicating that the NS3-G459L dominant mutant allows negative-strand synthesis and therefore specifically inhibits positive-strand synthesis.

β€” Results, "NS3-G459L Is a Dominant Inhibitor of WT Viral Growth"

Most importantly, viral genomes that abrogate this self-processing event trans-dominantly inhibit positive-strand RNA synthesis of WT genomes present in the same cell

β€” Discussion, "NS3 Internal Cleavage"

(F) Positive-strand replicon RNA was detected by strand-specific RT-qPCR. (G) Negative-strand replicon RNA was detected by strand-specific RT-qPCR (n = 2).

β€” Legend to Fig. 5

What the paper's own numbers show

There is no arithmetic to redo. The discrepancy is a reversed qualitative direction between two parts of the same paper describing one experiment: a strand-specific RT-qPCR of the luciferase replicon cotransfected with the NS3-G459L variant, measured at a single time point and normalized to the wild-type replicon alone, with the polymerase-dead GDD replicon as the no-synthesis reference. The two panels of that one experiment (Fig. 5F, positive strand; Fig. 5G, negative strand) are each reported relative to the GDD control. Taking those two relations as stated fixes which strand is inhibited.

quantity location reported recomputed (from the paper's own numbers)
Strand whose synthesis G459L inhibits Abstract negative-strand positive-strand
Positive-strand replicon RNA, G459L vs GDD-dead Results / Fig. 5F = GDD β†’ positive synthesis strongly inhibited positive-strand inhibited (consistent with body)
Negative-strand replicon RNA, G459L vs GDD-dead (n = 2) Results / Fig. 5G > GDD β†’ negative synthesis allowed negative-strand allowed, not inhibited
Strand inhibited (stated) Results conclusion positive-strand positive-strand
Strand inhibited (stated) Discussion positive-strand positive-strand

Four statements in the body (Fig. 5F, Fig. 5G, the Results conclusion, and the Discussion) place the inhibition on the positive strand; one statement in the abstract places it on the negative strand. recompute.py.txt encodes the two reported relations and prints VERDICT: claim CONFIRMED.

Figure

Two-panel diagram: the abstract sentence naming negative-strand synthesis as inhibited, versus the Results/Discussion showing positive-strand synthesis inhibited and negative-strand allowed, joined by a connector labeled "direction reversed."

The abstract (left, orange, as reported) states that negative-strand synthesis is inhibited. The Results and Discussion (right, blue, from the paper's own numbers) state that positive-strand synthesis is inhibited while negative-strand synthesis is allowed, based on the strand-specific RT-qPCR in Fig. 5F/G of the same cotransfection experiment. The connector names the conflict: the two descriptions assign the inhibition to opposite strands of one assay. Colors are reinforced by the panel labels and legend so the distinction does not rely on color alone.

Why it matters

Which RNA strand's synthesis is blocked is the mechanistic heart of this result. A reader using the abstract alone would conclude that the dominant-negative genome blocks negative-strand (template) synthesis, an early step of replication. The paper's data support the reverse: negative-strand synthesis proceeds and positive-strand (progeny genome) synthesis is specifically inhibited. Flavivirus and antiviral-mechanism researchers who cite the abstract without reading the Results could adopt an inverted picture of where in the replication cycle the trans-dominant block acts. The paper's broader conclusion β€” that abrogating the internal NS3 self-cleavage yields trans-dominant inhibition of viral replication, supporting the proposed antiviral strategy β€” is unaffected in direction, magnitude, or significance, because it does not depend on which strand is affected. The error is confined to one word of one abstract sentence and is contradicted correctly elsewhere in the same paper.

Explanations considered

Status

Suggested correction

In the abstract, change "dominantly inhibited negative-strand RNA synthesis of wild-type virus present in the same cell" to "dominantly inhibited positive-strand RNA synthesis of wild-type virus present in the same cell," making the abstract agree with the Results (Fig. 5 F and G), the Results conclusion, and the Discussion. No figure, table, or numeric value needs to change.