Paperonium

Protein science · Nat Commun · 2018

Summary: two proteins lower in cystic fibrosis cells. Data: neither measured alone; a relative 3× higher.

PKN1 and PKN4same as the other cellsThe summaryboth lowerIts own dataneither measured aloneA related protein, PKN2Its results3×higher
PKN1 and PKN4same as the other cellsThe summaryboth lowerIts own dataneither measured aloneA related protein, PKN2Its results3×higher

PKN protein levels in the cystic fibrosis cells, compared with the other cells

The paper says

The paper tests a new way of measuring proteins, including on two kinds of lab-grown human airway cells, one carrying a genetic change that causes cystic fibrosis. Its summary says the cystic fibrosis cells have less of two proteins, named PKN1 and PKN4.

Its own data show

In the cystic fibrosis cells, its results find a related protein, PKN2, three times as high, confirmed by a second kind of test. PKN1’s only measured fragment is half as high there, but PKN2 and PKN3 share it, so it cannot show which changed. PKN4 appears nowhere else in the paper or its data files.

PKN1, PKN2 and PKN3 are related but separate proteins, and the method identifies proteins by small fragments. The shared fragment could fit less PKN1, but the paper calls the PKN1 evidence conflicting. The standard human protein database has no PKN4. Summary readers would look for less PKN1 and PKN4; the double-checked finding is more PKN2.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Deducing the presence of proteins and proteoforms in quantitative proteomics · Nat Commun (2018) · doi:10.1038/s41467-018-04411-5