Schizophrenia care · Psychol Med · 2017
Paper: 1 extra remission for every 2 patients given mindfulness. Its own percentages: every 8.
Extra patients in remission for every 100 given mindfulness instead of the ordinary class
The paper says
Patients with schizophrenia took classes about their illness, ordinary or with mindfulness training. After 2 years, 38.9% with mindfulness were in remission (every symptom mild at most), against 27.0% without. Beside these figures the paper claims 1 extra remission for every 2 patients given mindfulness.
Its own data show
Those figures, also in its own table, differ by 38.9 − 27.0 = 11.9 patients in every 100, so 100 ÷ 11.9 = 8.4 patients must get mindfulness for 1 extra remission. Nor does the 2 match the study’s third group, who got neither class (7.4% in remission): against them, 100 ÷ 31.5 = 3.2.
The number of patients treated per extra remission is just 100 divided by the gap per 100 patients. So the paper overstates the benefit 8.4 ÷ 2 = 4.2 times. Its summary’s claim that mindfulness beats the ordinary class on remission rests on this comparison and on one other result given without enough detail to check.