Paperonium

Artery disease · Circulation · 2017

Paper says its trial was registered before patients joined. Registration came five months after they began.

2013201420175 monthslateBefore Dec 2012The paper saysregistered before anyone joinedDec 2012First patients joinMay 2013Registeredone main goal: artery openFeb 2014Safety addedas a second maingoal, 14 months inApr 2017The papernever mentions thelate registration orthe added goal
Before Dec 2012The paper saysregistered before anyone joinedDec 2012First patients join5 monthslateMay 2013Registeredone main goal: artery openFeb 2014Safety addedas a second main goal, 14 months inApr 2017The papernever mentions the lateregistration or the added goal

When the trial was registered and its goals changed, versus what the paper says

The paper says

Balloons inflated in narrowed leg arteries widen them. A trial found drug-coated balloons beat plain ones on both main goals: artery open after a year (84% vs 61%) and safety (94% vs 83%). The paper says the trial was registered publicly before anyone joined.

Its own data show

The trial’s public entry on ClinicalTrials.gov appeared in May 2013, five months after the first patients joined in December 2012 (the paper’s own date). It listed one main goal, artery open, and serious complications as a lesser goal. Safety (no death, amputation or repeat treatment) became a main goal in February 2014, 14 months in.

Main goals are the results a trial is judged on. Trials should post them publicly before anyone joins, so readers can check they were fixed before results came in. The safety goal, added 14 months in, can’t pass that check, yet half the paper’s win rests on it. The paper mentions neither the late registration nor the added goal.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Low-Dose Paclitaxel–Coated Versus Uncoated Percutaneous Transluminal Balloon Angioplasty for Femoropopliteal Peripheral Artery Disease · Circulation (2017) · doi:10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.116.026493