Paperonium

DNA chemistry · Nucleic Acids Res · 2017

The summary says lab-made letter pairs make DNA’s spiral twist more. Its own tables show less.

The summaryP–Z twists more than G–Csame as G–CIts Table 3, middle rungs12°less (P–Z 21.6°, G–C 33.6°)Its own main text“about 10° smaller”Its extra tablesall 7 turns smaller, by 1.5° to 12°
The summaryP–Z twists more than G–Csame as G–CIts Table 3, middle rungs12°less (P–Z 21.6°, G–C 33.6°)Its own main text“about 10° smaller”Its extra tablesall 7 turns smaller, by 1.5° to 12°

Twist: how far each rung turns from the last, P–Z compared with G–C

The paper says

DNA is a spiral staircase whose rungs are letter pairs, like G with C. Twist is the angle each rung turns from the one below. A computer simulation swapped six G–C rungs for a lab-made pair, P–Z. The paper’s opening summary says this adds twist.

Its own data show

Its own Table 3 shows the opposite. The two middle rungs turn 21.6° apart with P–Z and 33.6° with G–C: 12° less. The main text agrees. Extra tables published with it give all seven turns touching a P–Z rung: each is smaller, from 1.5° at the edges to 12° in the middle.

The summary is the part of a paper most readers, and search databases, take in. Here it is the only place that says P–Z adds twist; every twist number in the paper shows less. P and Z are lab-made letters meant to extend DNA’s four-letter alphabet, so anyone designing with them from the summary gets the direction backwards.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Consecutive non-natural PZ nucleobase pairs in DNA impact helical structure as seen in 50 μs molecular dynamics simulations · Nucleic Acids Res (2017) · doi:10.1093/nar/gkx144