Infection control · BMJ Glob Health · 2016
Paper’s summary: an infection-control workshop clearly improved two clinic habits. Its table: both could be chance.
Times as often staff kept 1.5 m from patients after the workshop
The paper says
After an infection-control workshop for clinic staff, the paper’s summary says staff kept 1.5 m from patients 1.09 times as often as before (plausible range 1.02 to 1.16, ruling out no change) and patients washed hands 1.19 times as often (range printed “1.3 to 1.25”).
Its own data show
Its Table 4 covers 221 observed patient check-ins at eight clinics: staff keeping 1.5 m rose from 91% to 99%, patients washing hands (alone or when told) from 82% to 99%. Grouping check-ins by clinic, as its methods specify, gives 1.11 (range 0.83 to 1.48) and 1.27 (0.95 to 1.71): either rise could be chance.
People at one clinic tend to act alike, so 221 check-ins from eight clinics say far less than 221 from 221 clinics would: the plausible range widens, while the middle value barely moves. The summary’s distance figures exactly match a calculation ignoring the clinics. Separately, its handwashing range is impossible: low end above high. Summary-only readers see two sure gains.