Paperonium

Biochemistry · Nucleic Acids Res · 2015

The paper’s summary swaps two enzyme parts’ jobs; its results and conclusion say the reverse.

The summaryIts resultsOpposite COpposite ABlock 513Block 51325× drop, vs 6.4× at CBlock 510Block 5107.6× drop, vs 5.1× at A
The summaryIts resultsOpposite COpposite ABlock 513Block 51325× drop, vs 6.4× at CBlock 510Block 5107.6× drop, vs 5.1× at A

Where each block mainly helps place damaged G, and the efficiency drop when changed

The paper says

A DNA-copying enzyme can place an oxygen-damaged G opposite C, its normal partner, or opposite A, a mistake. The paper’s summary says two of the enzyme’s building blocks (amino acids) each mainly help one of these: block 513 opposite C, block 510 opposite A.

Its own data show

The paper’s results and conclusion say the reverse, in three places, and its measurements (Table 1) back that. Changing block 513 made the enzyme 25 times less efficient at placing the damaged G opposite A, but 6.4 times opposite C. Changing block 510: 7.6 times opposite C, 5.1 times opposite A.

To learn a part’s job, scientists change it and see which job suffers most. Changing 510 hurts placement opposite C more, on both measures checked. Changing 513 hurts placement opposite A more, or both about equally if each drop is set against the drop for the correct, undamaged letter. Neither way supports the summary; its readers get it backwards.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Nucleotide binding interactions modulate dNTP selectivity and facilitate 8-oxo-dGTP incorporation by DNA polymerase lambda · Nucleic Acids Res (2015) · doi:10.1093/nar/gkv760