Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Abstract pairs Ala510 with dA and Asn513 with dC; the paper's Results and Conclusion pair them the other way round

Nucleic Acids Res (2015) · doi:10.1093/nar/gkv760 · PMC4652769

Summary

The abstract states that "Ala510 and Asn513 facilitate incorporation of 8-oxo-dGMP opposite dA and dC, respectively". The body of the paper states the reverse pairing three times. The N513A paragraph of the Results concludes that "Asn513 plays an important role in facilitating 8-oxo-dGMP incorporation opposite dA". The Conclusion states that "Ala510 selectively enhances the incorporation of 8-oxo-dGMP opposite dC". The double-mutant paragraph describes "the opposite effects of Ala510 and Asn513, facilitating incorporation of the anti- and syn-conformations, respectively", and the paper ties the syn conformation to dA and the anti conformation to dC. The contradiction is between the abstract and the paper's own text, and that internal contradiction is the main basis of this report.

Table 1 supports the body text's assignment for Ala510 under both ways of summarising the data that I checked. For Asn513 the data support the body text (dA) on the absolute metric and are about even on the alternative metric; on neither metric do they support the abstract's dC assignment. The underlying kinetics and the Results text are internally consistent; the error is confined to one sentence of the abstract.

What the paper reports

Abstract (as archived in PMC):

Steady-state kinetics reveal that two residues lining the dNTP binding pocket, Ala510 and Asn513, play differential roles in dNTP selectivity. Specifically, Ala510 and Asn513 facilitate incorporation of 8-oxo-dGMP opposite dA and dC, respectively.

Results and Discussion, N513A paragraph:

However, the N513A substitution resulted in a much more drastic effect in the context of 8-oxo-dGMP incorporation opposite dA (25-fold, Figure 3D). Also, the catalytic efficiencies of dGMP and 8-oxo-dGMP incorporation opposite dC were reduced by 1.3 (Figure 3E) and 6.4-fold (Figure 3F) respectively. Taken together, these results suggest that Asn513 plays an important role in facilitating 8-oxo-dGMP incorporation opposite dA, implying that this residue selectively stabilizes the syn-conformation of 8-oxo-dGTP.

Results and Discussion, A510D paragraph:

Notably, the A510D substitution had the largest effect on the incorporation of 8-oxo-dGTP opposite dC (7.6-fold, Figure 3E) as opposed to dGTP (2.8-fold, Figure 3F). This suggests that Ala510 may preferentially stabilize the anti-conformation of 8-oxo-dGTP, promoting its incorporation opposite dC.

Results and Discussion, double-mutant paragraph:

Interestingly, the drop in catalytic efficiency was nearly identical for 8-oxo-dGMP incorporation opposite dA and dC. This is consistent with the opposite effects of Ala510 and Asn513, facilitating incorporation of the anti- and syn-conformations, respectively.

Conclusion:

As a consequence, Ala510 selectively enhances the incorporation of 8-oxo-dGMP opposite dC.

So the Results, the double-mutant interpretation and the Conclusion all assign Asn513 to the dA (syn) context and Ala510 to the dC (anti) context. The abstract's sentence assigns them the other way round.

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. Table 1 gives the catalytic efficiency kcat/KM (min⁻¹ µM⁻¹, mean ± SD of three independent experiments) for WT and each mutant, for the correct dNTP and for 8-oxo-dGTP, opposite both dA and dC. From those values I recomputed the fold loss of kcat/KM caused by each substitution (WT ÷ mutant) and compared it with the fold values printed in the Results text. I summarise each residue's template preference two ways, because the answer for Asn513 depends on which one is used:

Approximate SDs are first-order (delta-method) propagations of the Table 1 SDs on the log scale, treating WT and mutant as independent; with n = 3 per estimate they are a rough guide only. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from Table 1
A510D fold loss, 8-oxo-dGTP opposite dA Results 5.1-fold 5.11× (SD ~0.65)
A510D fold loss, 8-oxo-dGTP opposite dC Results 7.6-fold 7.57× (SD ~1.67)
N513A fold loss, 8-oxo-dGTP opposite dA Results 25-fold 24.74× (SD ~3.19)
N513A fold loss, 8-oxo-dGTP opposite dC Results 6.4-fold 6.39× (SD ~0.71)
A510D fold loss, dTTP opposite dA Results 4.8-fold 4.78×
A510D fold loss, dGTP opposite dC Results 2.8-fold 2.76×
N513A fold loss, dTTP opposite dA Results 5.8-fold 5.82×
N513A fold loss, dGTP opposite dC Results 1.3-fold 1.33×

The Results-text values and the values recomputed from Table 1 agree throughout, so the contradiction is not between the Results and the table; it is between the abstract and the rest of the paper.

Which context does each residue affect more?

Residue Metric 1 (absolute): dA vs dC larger at Metric 2 (÷ correct dNTP): dA vs dC larger at
Ala510 (A510D) 5.11× vs 7.57× dC (ratio 1.48; |log diff|/SD ~1.5) 1.07 vs 2.74 dC (ratio 2.57; |log diff|/SD ~2.6)
Asn513 (N513A) 24.74× vs 6.39× dA (ratio 3.87; |log diff|/SD ~7.9) 4.25 vs 4.79 about equal (ratio 1.13; |log diff|/SD ~0.4)

Reading. On the absolute metric the pairing is the clean reverse of the abstract: Ala510's larger effect is opposite dC, Asn513's is opposite dA (and the Asn513 gap is large, ~8 approximate SDs). On the relative metric Ala510 is again larger opposite dC, by a clear margin, while Asn513 is essentially even between the two contexts (4.25 vs 4.79, well under one approximate SD apart). So:

A consistency check favours the body text. For the double mutant the fold loss is nearly identical opposite dA (55.8×) and dC (58.9×), which the paper reads as Ala510 and Asn513 having opposite template preferences that cancel. That reading requires Asn513 → dA and Ala510 → dC, i.e. the body text, not the abstract. The Results also note that removing Asn513 cripples 8-oxo-dGTP opposite dA (25-fold) far more than it does the correct dTTP in the same context (5.8-fold), which is the paper's own argument that Asn513 selectively helps the dA (syn) mispair.

Figure

Left, the abstract pairs Ala510 with dA and Asn513 with dC; right, the Results, Conclusion and double-mutant text pair them the other way, and the Table 1 fold losses recomputed below agree with the body text

Figure 1. The abstract's sentence (left, orange) pairs Ala510 with the dA context and Asn513 with the dC context. The Results, Conclusion and double-mutant paragraphs (right) pair them the other way: Asn513 with dA (syn), Ala510 with dC (anti). The strip below lists, recomputed from Table 1, the fold loss of kcat/KM for 8-oxo-dGTP in each context, both as the absolute loss and divided by the loss for the correct dNTP (blue). Blue values are recomputed by recompute.py.txt; the abstract gives no numbers. The Results text prints the same absolute values, rounded.

Design candidates for review. recompute.py.txt also writes five candidate layouts in candidates/ (cand1–cand5). fig1 is currently a copy of cand1 (the two-panel text diagram) and fig2 a copy of cand3 (a one-axis log plot of the fold losses). The final figure choice is open until the reader picks from the five candidates.

Why it matters

Explanations considered

Status

Suggested correction

In the abstract, replace

Specifically, Ala510 and Asn513 facilitate incorporation of 8-oxo-dGMP opposite dA and dC, respectively.

with

Specifically, Ala510 and Asn513 facilitate incorporation of 8-oxo-dGMP opposite dC and dA, respectively.

(or, equivalently, "Asn513 and Ala510 ... opposite dA and dC, respectively"), so that the abstract agrees with the Results, the Conclusion, the double-mutant interpretation and Table 1.