Brain injury · Ann Neurol · 2014
Summary: chance gives this DNA-and-aging brain-injury finding 1 in 500. Its own table: 1 in 50.
How often chance alone makes DNA type seem to change age’s toll on recovery
The paper says
Among 1,094 brain-injury patients, older age meant worse recovery at six months. The paper says how much worse depended on inherited mitochondrial DNA type (DNA of the cell’s energy-making parts); its summary and main text say chance alone would produce this 1 time in 500.
Its own data show
The paper’s own Table 3 prints 0.02 for the same test: 2 in 100, or 1 in 50. The test boils the data down to one score, where bigger means rarer by chance. The table’s score, 13.4, gives about 1 in 50; 1 in 500 would need 18.9. The table’s other results match their scores.
“1 in N” is how often chance alone would produce a pattern this strong if DNA type made no difference. Both figures beat the paper’s pass mark of 1 in 20, but the summary makes the pattern look ten times rarer by chance than the table does. The claim that two DNA types protect older patients rests on this test.