Nutrition · Gastroenterology · 2012
The paper’s summary: a healthier diet cut a blood toxin 31%. Its results and chart: 38%.
Same eight people, same healthier month: how much the blood toxin fell
The paper says
Eight healthy people on a hospital ward ate a Western diet for one month and a healthier diet for another. The paper’s opening summary says a bacterial toxin in their blood rose 71% during the Western month and fell 31% during the healthier one.
Its own data show
Its results section says 38% for the same people and month. The paper prints no group levels, but its chart shows each person’s level at the start and end of each month. Measured off that chart, the group’s average fell 37.5% over the healthier month: 35.4% to 39.5%, allowing for error in reading each point.
A group’s change can be measured two ways: the change in its average, or the average of each person’s change. On the chart, the first gives 37.5% down and 72% up, matching the results section; the second, 33% down but 80% up. Neither gives the summary’s 31% and 71% together, so the summary probably understates how much the diet helped.