Paperonium

Diabetes · Diabetes Care · 2012

Summary: the drug tripled how much a gut hormone rises after a meal. Results section: sevenfold.

The summary: 43.2 to 127.12.9 times as highIts results: 27.5 to 200.37.3 times as high02468
The summary: 43.2 to 127.12.9 times as highIts results: 27.5 to 200.37.3 times as high02468

How many times as high the hormone’s after-meal rise was after 8 weeks

The paper says

20 people ate the same test meal before and after 8 weeks on colesevelam, a drug that improved blood sugar after meals. The paper’s summary: a gut hormone’s rise, added up over 2 hours, nearly tripled, from 43.2 to 127.1 (middle value of the 20).

Its own data show

The results section, the detailed part after the short summary at the top, gives the same measurement in the same 20 people as 27.5 before and 200.3 after: 7.3 times as high, against the summary’s 2.9. Three other after-meal results printed in both places, including blood sugar, match exactly: only this one differs.

A middle value has half the group above it and half below, so the same 20 people at one visit have exactly one. At least one version is wrong; nothing in the paper shows which. Both show a rise, but its size is unknown, and the summary says this rise may partly explain the drug’s effect on blood sugar.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Colesevelam Improves Oral but Not Intravenous Glucose Tolerance by a Mechanism Independent of Insulin Sensitivity and β-Cell Function · Diabetes Care (2012) · doi:10.2337/dc11-2050