Paperonium

Blood clots · BMJ · 2011

Summary: 41 lung clots in women who sat most. Its table: in women who sat least.

Lung clotsThe summaryIts own table41Women who sat mostin 104,720 woman-years16Women who sat mostin 14,565 woman-years16Women who sat leastin 14,565 woman-years41Women who sat leastin 104,720 woman-years
Lung clotsThe summaryIts own table41Women whosat mostin 104,720woman-years16Women whosat mostin 14,565woman-years16Women whosat leastin 14,565woman-years41Women whosat leastin 104,720woman-years

Lung clots, and woman-years followed, in the women who sat most and least

The paper says

The summary says women who sat most were 2.34 times as likely as those who sat least to get a blood clot in the lungs with no obvious cause. Its counts: 41 clots in 104,720 woman-years for the most, 16 in 14,565 for the least.

Its own data show

Its own table gives each pair to the other group: 16 clots in 14,565 woman-years for the 1,829 women who sat most, and 41 in 104,720 for the 12,451 who sat least. Only the summary’s group names are wrong; its 2.34 times, from the same table, is unaffected.

A woman-year is one woman followed for one year. A bigger group collects more clots at the same risk, so risk is clots per woman-year: about 110 per 100,000 for the women who sat most, about 39 for those who sat least. Read as printed, the summary’s counts make sitting most look safer, contradicting its own finding.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Physical inactivity and idiopathic pulmonary embolism in women: prospective study · BMJ (2011) · doi:10.1136/bmj.d3867