Paperonium

Parasitic disease · PLoS Pathog · 2012

Summary: silencing a gene “increased” nitric oxide. It stayed flat; only the comparison cells’ level fell.

Silenced cellsThe summarynitric oxide “increased”Its chartflat: 5.4 and 5.5same as uninfectedComparison cellsIts chartfell: 6.3 to 4.0
Silenced cellsThe summarynitric oxide “increased”Its chartflat: 5.4 and 5.5same as uninfectedComparison cellsIts chartfell: 6.3 to 4.0

Nitric oxide (µM) read from the paper’s chart, uninfected and infected cells

The paper says

In cells infected with a parasite, silencing the cells’ own arginase 1 gene cut parasite numbers. The paper’s summary says this also “led to increased generation of nitric oxide,” a chemical that, in the usual account, kills this parasite.

Its own data show

The paper prints no nitric oxide numbers. Read from its chart, in µM (a unit of concentration): silenced cells, 5.4 uninfected and 5.5 infected; comparison cells, whose treatment targeted no gene, 6.3 and 4.0. Four other places in the paper say, or suggest, that silencing the gene did not raise nitric oxide.

“Increased” needs a comparison. Against infected comparison cells, silenced cells had more, 5.5 vs 4.0 µM, because the comparison cells’ level fell; the chart does not mark this gap as beyond chance. Against their own uninfected level, no rise. Read alone, the summary suggests extra nitric oxide killed the parasite; the paper itself credits a different mechanism.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Progressive Visceral Leishmaniasis Is Driven by Dominant Parasite-induced STAT6 Activation and STAT6-dependent Host Arginase 1 Expression · PLoS Pathog (2012) · doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1002417