Paperonium

Vaccination · PLoS Med · 2011

Madagascar’s vaccine reach: the summary’s range, 78⁠–⁠81%, leaves out its best guess, 77%. Its table: 76⁠–⁠78%.

The summaryleaves out its own best guessIts results tableincludes its best guess77%78 to 81%should be inside76 to 78%76%77%78%79%80%81%
The summaryleaves out its ownbest guessIts results tableincludes itsbest guess77%78 to 81%should be inside76 to 78%76%78%80%82%

Share of Madagascar’s children that measles vaccination can ever reach

The paper says

The paper estimates what share of a country’s children measles vaccination can ever reach; the rest never get a chance at any routine shot or mass campaign. Its opening summary gives Madagascar a best guess of 77%, with a range of 78% to 81%.

Its own data show

By the paper’s own method, a best guess always sits inside its range. Further in, its results table gives the same 77% with a range of 76% to 78%. Its written results say 23% can never be reached, range 22% to 24%, which leaves the same 76% to 78% within reach.

A range shows how sure the paper is: the true share very likely lies somewhere inside it. The 77% and the paper’s conclusions are unaffected. But anyone who takes the range from the summary, where the main findings are, gets 78% to 81% instead of 76% to 78%.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Measuring the Performance of Vaccination Programs Using Cross-Sectional Surveys: A Likelihood Framework and Retrospective Analysis · PLoS Med (2011) · doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001110