Paperonium

Health costs · Diabetes Care · 2009

Hurricane Katrina’s diabetes cost: the paper’s $504 million counts 66,563 veterans, not 4,438. Corrected: $261.5 million.

The summary’s total$504.2M66,563 veterans, not 4,438Its own numbers, counted right$261.5M$0$200M$400M$600M
The summary’s total$504.2M66,563 veterans, not 4,438Its own numbers,counted right$261.5M$0$200M$400M$600M

Hurricane Katrina’s added lifetime diabetes cost, greater New Orleans

The paper says

Of greater New Orleans’ 964,677 adults, 9.2% (88,750) have diabetes, split among three health systems: a public hospital system 20% (17,750), private insurance 75% (66,563), the veterans’ system 5% (4,438). Summary: Hurricane Katrina adds $504 million to their costs over the rest of their lives.

Its own data show

The paper’s Table 3 multiplies each group’s extra cost per patient by its head count. For veterans it uses their own $3,907 but the privately insured count, 66,563, not 4,438, so about 150,875 people are counted, not 88,750. Paper: $93.1M + $151.1M + $260.1M ≈ $504.2M. Correct: $93.1M + $151.1M + $17.3M = $261.5M.

A group’s cost is its extra cost per patient times its head count, and the counts must total 88,750. Per-patient costs are a computer model’s forecast from how blood sugar, blood pressure and blood fats changed after the storm. The wrong veterans figure alone ($260.1M) almost equals the correct total ($261.5M), so the summary’s only dollar figure is nearly double.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Impact of a Natural Disaster on Diabetes · Diabetes Care (2009) · doi:10.2337/dc09-0670