Paperonium

Lung cancer · Nucleic Acids Res · 2008

Summary: lung tumors don’t raise a gene’s short version. Its data: 36.42 times the healthy level.

The summary: short versionnot raisedIts data: short versionraised mostIts data: long versionmatching the summary36.42×3.531×2×5×10×20×50×same as healthy lung
The summary:short versionnot raisedIts data:short versionraised mostIts data:long versionmatching thesummary36.42×3.531×3×10×100×same as healthy lung

Amount of each version in tumors, as a multiple of healthy lung, same patients

The paper says

Cells can skip a section of a gene when copying it, so the gene CEACAM1 comes in long and short versions. The paper’s summary (its opening paragraph) says lung tumors make more of the long one than healthy lung, but not the short one.

Its own data show

Its results compare tumor and healthy lung of 35 patients. Both versions rose: the long one to 3.53 times the healthy level, as the summary says; the short one, which the summary says did not rise, to 36.42 times, ten times the long one’s figure (36.42 ÷ 3.53 = 10.3). Its discussion backs the results.

The two versions can do different jobs: an earlier study the paper cites found the long one holds tumors back. So a reader of the summary alone would think lung tumors make more of that tumor-restraining version and not the other, when the paper’s own data put the big rise in the short one.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Whole genome exon arrays identify differential expression of alternatively spliced, cancer-related genes in lung cancer · Nucleic Acids Res (2008) · doi:10.1093/nar/gkn697