Anaesthesia · JAMA Netw Open · 2026
A trial pins a breathing-tube camera’s gain to 4.45–4.78 per 100 patients. Its counts allow 0.8–8.5.
Extra patients per 100 whose tube went in first try: camera versus plain tool
The paper says
A trial tested tools for placing a breathing tube in the windpipe. Its summary says a camera tool got the tube in on the first try for 4.66 more patients per 100 than a plain one, and pins that gain to between 4.45 and 4.78.
Its own data show
Its table: first-try success for 673 of 812 patients (82.9%) with the camera tool, 625 of 799 (78.2%) with the plain one. By the method the paper names, the gain could be anywhere from 0.8 to 8.5. A range as narrow as the summary’s would need about 440,000 patients per tool, not about 800.
No trial measures a gain exactly, so it reports a range: the values its data can’t rule out. More patients make the range narrower. The 4.66 is right, but the summary’s range is 0.33 wide; the counts support one 7.7 wide, 23 times wider. The camera tool still comes out ahead, but perhaps by as little as 0.8 per 100.