Mental health · Psychol Med · 2026
Summary: childhood problems explain 37% of the smoking-in-pregnancy link to teen suicide attempts. Paper’s numbers: 23%.
Share of the smoking link explained by childhood problems
The paper says
Teens whose mothers smoked while pregnant were about twice as likely to attempt suicide. The summary says 37% of that link runs along a chain, smoking to childhood problems to attempts: 16% via anxiety and low mood, 12% disruptive behavior, 9% trouble with other children.
Its own data show
The paper’s own measures of each route’s strength put the anxiety-and-low-mood route at 1.6% of the whole link, not 16%. Its results section prints 16% anyway, and the summary repeats it. Yet that section gives 23% for all three routes, and only 1.6 fits that: 1.6 + 12.3 + 9.2 = 23.1.
A route’s share is how much of the whole link travels through it. The three routes together carry 23%; the other 77% runs outside them. The summary’s 37% is too high, and it ranks anxiety and low mood first, though that route is the smallest, too small to tell apart from zero.