Paperonium

Mental health · Psychol Med · 2026

Summary: childhood problems explain 37% of the smoking-in-pregnancy link to teen suicide attempts. Paper’s numbers: 23%.

All three problems23.1%Its own numbers37%The summarytoo highAnxiety, low mood1.6%Its own numbers16%The summary and results0%10203040
All three problems23.1%Its own numbers37%The summarytoo highAnxiety, low mood1.6%Its own numbers16%The summaryand results0%10203040

Share of the smoking link explained by childhood problems

The paper says

Teens whose mothers smoked while pregnant were about twice as likely to attempt suicide. The summary says 37% of that link runs along a chain, smoking to childhood problems to attempts: 16% via anxiety and low mood, 12% disruptive behavior, 9% trouble with other children.

Its own data show

The paper’s own measures of each route’s strength put the anxiety-and-low-mood route at 1.6% of the whole link, not 16%. Its results section prints 16% anyway, and the summary repeats it. Yet that section gives 23% for all three routes, and only 1.6 fits that: 1.6 + 12.3 + 9.2 = 23.1.

A route’s share is how much of the whole link travels through it. The three routes together carry 23%; the other 77% runs outside them. The summary’s 37% is too high, and it ranks anxiety and low mood first, though that route is the smallest, too small to tell apart from zero.

“The summary” means the paper’s abstract: the short summary printed at its top, which is the part most readers see.

Read the paper →Full technical write-up →

Mediating mechanisms of the association between prenatal tobacco exposure and adolescent suicide attempt: A 17-year longitudinal study · Psychol Med (2026) · doi:10.1017/S0033291725102936