Paperonium

← Back to the plain-language case

Abstract says mediators explain 37% of the association; the paper's coefficients give 23%

Psychol Med (2026) · doi:10.1017/S0033291725102936 · PMC13092991

Summary

The abstract states that childhood internalizing symptoms, externalizing behaviors and peer problems account for "37% of the total association" between prenatal tobacco exposure and adolescent suicide attempt, split as 16%, 12% and 9%. The paper defines the proportion mediated as the indirect association divided by the total association, β = 0.731. The paper's own coefficients give an internalizing share of 1.6% (0.012 / 0.731), not 16%, and a combined share of 23.1% (0.169 / 0.731). The Results state 23% for the combined share, and the Discussion says "more than one-fifth". The abstract's 37% is the sum 16 + 12 + 9, so it carries the ten-fold internalizing figure. The abstract's headline result therefore overstates the mediated share by about 14 percentage points. It also presents a non-significant pathway (OR 1.01, 95% CI 0.99 to 1.03) as the largest of the three mediators.

What the paper reports

Abstract, Results:

In models adjusted for key covariates, we found a significant association between prenatal tobacco exposure and increased risk of adolescent suicide attempts (odds ratio = 2.08, 95% confidence interval = [1.68, 2.56]), partly mediated through internalizing problems, externalizing behaviors, and peer problems from ages 3 to 14 years (accounting for 37% of the total association, that is, 16%, 12%, and 9%, respectively).

Methods, "Mediation analysis", which defines the quantities:

Indirect associations were calculated using the product of the coefficient approach (i.e. the product of the coefficient for the association between exposure and mediator, and between mediator and outcome).

The remaining unexplained part was represented by the direct association (total association = indirect + direct associations). The proportion of the association mediated was also calculated as the ratio between the indirect association and total association, to better understand the relative importance of each mediator.

Results, "Association between maternal smoking during pregnancy and childhood psychosocial difficulties" (the exposure-to-mediator paths):

Children whose mothers smoked during pregnancy were more likely to exhibit internalizing symptoms (β = 0.205, SE = 0.031, p < 0.001), externalizing behaviors (β = 0.477, SE = 0.031, p < 0.001), and peer problems (β = 0.279, SE = 0.031, p < 0.001) across their childhood.

Results, "Association between childhood psychosocial difficulties and adolescent suicide attempt" (the mediator-to-outcome paths):

We found that externalizing behaviors (β = 0.188, SE = 0.051, p < 0.001; OR = 1.21, 95% CI = [1.09, 1.33]) and peer problems (β = 0.241, SE = 0.052, p < 0.001; OR = 1.27, 95% CI = [1.15, 1.41]) from ages 3 to 14 increased the likelihood of later suicide attempt. Internalizing symptoms were not significantly associated with increased likelihood of suicide attempt (β = 0.057, SE = 0.052, p = 0.278; OR = 1.06, 95% CI = [0.96, 1.17]).

Results, "Pathways of association between maternal smoking during pregnancy and adolescent suicide attempt":

Structural equation models demonstrated that prenatal smoking was significantly associated with an increased risk of suicide attempt in adolescence (total association: β = 0.731, SE = 0.107, OR = 2.08, 95% CI = [1.68, 2.56]) after adjusting for the selected covariates.

Mediation analysis showed that 12.3% of the association was explained by externalizing behaviors (indirect association: β = 0.90, SE = 0.025, OR = 1.09, 95% CI = [1.04, 1.15]), and 9.2% by peer problems (indirect association: β = 0.057, SE = 0.025, OR = 1.07, 95% CI = [1.03, 1.11]). Internalizing symptoms explained 16% of the association, although the indirect association was not statistically significant (β = 0.012, SE = 0.011, OR = 1.01, 95% CI = [0.99, 1.03]) (Figure 2).

The proportion of the total effect mediated through all three mediators was estimated at 23% (overall indirect effect: β = 0.169, SE = 0.023, OR = 1.18, 95% CI = [1.13, 1.24]), suggesting that ~23% of the association between prenatal smoking and adolescent suicide attempts is attributed to these mediators. The direct association of prenatal tobacco exposure on suicide attempts remained significant (β = 0.562, SE = 0.107, OR = 1.75, 95% CI = [1.42, 2.16]).

Discussion, fourth paragraph:

Externalizing behaviors and peer problems accounted for 12.3% and 9.2% of the association between prenatal smoking exposure and suicide attempt, respectively. This indicates that psychosocial difficulties collectively mediated more than one-fifth of this association.

Table 2, whole sample, adjusted columns (OR, 95% CI): total association 2.08 (1.68–2.56); direct 1.75 (1.42–2.16); indirect via internalizing symptoms 1.01 (0.99–1.03); via externalizing behaviors 1.09 (1.04–1.15); via peer problems 1.07 (1.03–1.11); total indirect 1.18 (1.13–1.24).

What the paper's own numbers show

Method. The Methods give three rules, and the paper prints every input they need. (1) Each indirect association is the product a × b of the exposure-to-mediator coefficient and the mediator-to-outcome coefficient. (2) Total = direct + indirect. (3) The proportion mediated is indirect / total. All coefficients are on the log-odds scale: exp(β) reproduces each printed OR. I applied the three rules to the printed coefficients. As independent checks I also took the log-scale centre of each printed 95% CI and the log of each printed OR. No raw data are available, so the model was not refitted. Every number below is printed by recompute.py.txt.

Quantity Location Reported Recomputed from the paper's own numbers
Total association, β (OR) Results; Table 2 0.731 (2.08) exp(0.731) = 2.077, consistent
Direct association, β (OR) Results; Table 2 0.562 (1.75) exp(0.562) = 1.754, consistent
Overall indirect, β (OR) Results; Table 2 0.169 (1.18) 0.731 − 0.562 = 0.169; sum of a × b = 0.1686; CI centre 0.1687
Internalizing indirect, β Results 0.012 (OR 1.01, CI 0.99–1.03) 0.205 × 0.057 = 0.0117; CI centre 0.0098; consistent
Externalizing indirect, β Results 0.90 (OR 1.09, CI 1.04–1.15) 0.477 × 0.188 = 0.0897; CI centre 0.0895. exp(0.90) = 2.46, not 1.09, so 0.90 is a misprint of 0.090
Peer problems indirect, β Results 0.057 (OR 1.07, CI 1.03–1.11) 0.279 × 0.241 = 0.0672; CI centre 0.0670; exp(0.057) = 1.059, not 1.07, so 0.057 is a misprint of about 0.067
Share mediated, internalizing Results; Abstract 16% 0.0117 / 0.731 = 1.6% (from printed 0.012: 1.64%)
Share mediated, externalizing Results; Abstract 12.3%; 12% 0.0897 / 0.731 = 12.3%, consistent
Share mediated, peer problems Results; Abstract 9.2%; 9% 0.0672 / 0.731 = 9.2%, consistent
Share mediated, all three Results; Discussion 23%; "more than one-fifth" 0.169 / 0.731 = 23.1%; 1.6 + 12.3 + 9.2 = 23.1%, consistent
Share mediated, all three Abstract 37% (16 + 12 + 9) 23.1%
Sum of the components printed in the Results Results 16 + 12.3 + 9.2 = 37.5% contradicts the 23% printed in the same paragraph
Indirect β the 16% would require — — 0.16 × 0.731 = 0.117 (OR 1.12, about 9.7 × the printed 0.012; 95% CI with the printed SE 1.10 to 1.15)
Overall indirect and direct β the 37% would require — — indirect 0.270 (OR 1.31); direct 0.461 (OR 1.58), against the printed 0.169 (OR 1.18) and 0.562 (OR 1.75)
Direct share of the total implied 63% if the abstract held 0.562 / 0.731 = 76.9%

Three independent routes give the same decomposition: the product of coefficients, the total − direct identity, and the CI centres. All three put the overall indirect association at 0.169 and the internalizing component at about 0.01. The 12.3%, 9.2% and 23% in the Results agree with them. The only figures that disagree are the internalizing 16%, which appears in both the Results and the Abstract, and the abstract's 37%, which is built from it.

Two smaller slips, noted in passing, do not affect the finding. The Results give "1,229 (17%)" children as exposed, but 1,229 / 8,861 = 13.9%. And the sentence after the total association (OR 2.08) reads "1.75 times higher odds", which is the direct OR.

Figure

Printed vs recomputed share of the association mediated by each childhood mediator and by all three together

Figure 1. Share of the total association between prenatal tobacco exposure and adolescent suicide attempt (β = 0.731) that is mediated by each mediator and by all three together. Orange circles are the values printed in the Results and the Abstract. Blue diamonds are recomputed by recompute.py.txt as indirect / total, with each indirect association taken as the product of the paper's printed exposure-to-mediator and mediator-to-outcome coefficients. The overall share is the printed 0.169 / 0.731. Externalizing behaviors, peer problems and the Results' 23% agree with the recomputed values. The internalizing share (16% printed, 1.6% recomputed) and the abstract's combined 37% (23.1% recomputed) do not. The axis starts at zero.

The abstract's split of the total association compared with the split implied by the paper's direct and indirect coefficients

Figure 2. The same total association split into its direct and indirect parts. Top (orange): the split stated in the abstract, 16% + 12% + 9% = 37% mediated. The 63% direct share is not printed; it is implied as 100 − 37. Bottom (blue): the split given by the paper's own coefficients, direct 0.562 / 0.731 = 76.9% and indirect 1.6% + 12.3% + 9.2% = 23.1%. Because total = direct + indirect, the abstract's 37% cannot be squared with the direct association the paper reports: it would require a direct β of 0.461 (OR 1.58) instead of the printed 0.562 (OR 1.75).

Why it matters

Explanations considered

The pattern fits a shifted decimal (1.6% printed as 16%) that was then carried into the abstract's sum. The printed externalizing β of 0.90 for 0.090 is a misprint of the same kind. The cause cannot be determined from the paper.

Status

As of 2026-10-24:

Sources: version of record; PMC13092991; Crossref record.

Suggested correction