Dementia care · BMJ Glob Health · 2026
The summary uses 14 of 17 studies; with all 17, mixed carer support is unproven.
Cut in carers’ strain, questionnaire points; bars show values the data can’t rule out
The paper says
The paper’s summary says support programmes for carers of people with dementia in poorer countries cut their strain by 8.7 points on a standard questionnaire, and programmes mixing face-to-face and remote contact cut it by 20.9 (a range of 5.8 to 36.0, all above zero).
Its own data show
The paper’s results section and Figure 3 use all 17 studies. There, mixed programmes rest on 3 studies, not 2: 14.5 points, a range of −2.7 to 31.7, which includes zero. The overall cut barely moves: 8.1, not 8.7. Recalculating from Figure 3 without the 3 newest studies (2024–25) gives every number in the summary.
A range is the span of values the data can’t rule out; if it includes zero, ‘no benefit’ is still possible. With all 17 studies, mixed programmes (just 3 studies) might help but aren’t shown to. The summary, the part most people read, makes them look clearly helpful and the strongest kind. The overall benefit holds either way.